<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss version="2.0"
	xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"
	xmlns:wfw="http://wellformedweb.org/CommentAPI/"
	xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"
	xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"
	xmlns:sy="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/syndication/"
	xmlns:slash="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/slash/"
	>

<channel>
	<title>Createquity.Createquity.</title>
	<atom:link href="https://createquity.com/author/taliagibas/feed/" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
	<link>https://createquity.com</link>
	<description>The most important issues in the arts...and what we can do about them.</description>
	<lastBuildDate>Wed, 15 Jul 2020 20:17:39 +0000</lastBuildDate>
	<language>en-US</language>
	<sy:updatePeriod>hourly</sy:updatePeriod>
	<sy:updateFrequency>1</sy:updateFrequency>
	<generator>https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.5</generator>
	<item>
		<title>Capsule Review: Do Donors Care About Results?</title>
		<link>https://createquity.com/2017/08/capsule-review-do-donors-care-about-results/</link>
		<comments>https://createquity.com/2017/08/capsule-review-do-donors-care-about-results/#respond</comments>
		<pubDate>Mon, 21 Aug 2017 16:13:03 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Talia Gibas]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[Insider]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[arts philanthropy]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[capsule review]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[cultural asset mapping]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[nonprofit sector]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://createquity.com/?p=10297</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[A US study find that foundation contributions decrease as organizations’ audiences and web viewerships grow.]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="attachment_10299" style="width: 570px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img fetchpriority="high" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-10299" class="wp-image-10299" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/Money-300x201.jpg" alt="Money" width="560" height="375" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/Money-300x201.jpg 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/Money-768x514.jpg 768w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/Money.jpg 1024w" sizes="(max-width: 560px) 100vw, 560px" /><p id="caption-attachment-10299" class="wp-caption-text">&#8220;Money,&#8221; by Flickr user Clayton</p></div>
<p><b>Title: </b>Do Donors Care About Results? An Analysis of Nonprofit Arts and Cultural Organizations</p>
<p><b>Author(s)</b>: Cleopatra Charles and Mirae Kim</p>
<p><b>Publisher</b>: Public Performance and Management Review</p>
<p><b>Year</b>: 2016</p>
<p><b>URL</b>: <a href="http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/15309576.2015.1137775?journalCode=mpmr20" target="_blank">http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/15309576.2015.1137775?journalCode=mpmr20</a></p>
<p><b>Topics</b>: Cultural Data Project, nonprofit success metrics, philanthropy</p>
<p><b>Methods</b>: Analysis of attendance, website engagement, and financial data from a subset of arts and culture organizations that complete Cultural Data Profiles between 2005 and 2015</p>
<p><b>What it says</b>: This study examines whether nonprofit arts organizations with better “performance outcomes” – defined by higher attendance numbers, audience “awareness of arts and culture activities” (measured through website visits), and “increased access to diverse audiences” (measured through the number of free tickets provided) – receive more contributions than other arts nonprofits. It also examines whether nonprofit arts organizations with lower overall fundraising costs (measured through the ratio of development expense to dollars raised) receive more contributions than organizations that spend more to bring money in the door.  The authors find that foundation contributions decrease as organizations’ audiences and web viewerships grow. The impact of audience growth on individual donations is also negative but much smaller, while the impact on corporate donations is not statistically significant. The relationship between fundraising expense and donations is similarly split, but in the opposite direction: as organizations spend more per fundraised dollar, foundation giving goes <i>up</i>, while individual and corporate donations are not visibly impacted.</p>
<p>In discussing these findings, the authors conclude that certain performance outcomes for arts organizations have little to no relationship to their success with donors; in fact, “better performance outcomes in terms of increased awareness and attendance have a negative rather than a positive influence on charitable giving,” specifically related to foundations.</p>
<p><b>What I think about it</b>: It’s tempting to get hung up on this study’s limitations – for example, its dubious use of attendance numbers and website visits as proxies for success, it’s reliance on self-reported Cultural Data Project (CDP) data, and it’s lack of a random sample. The latter point is particularly problematic because it’s difficult to glean the total sample size of the organizations analyzed. The authors note they only focus on organizations with audited financials (which excluded a whopping 52% of the overall pool) and further removed organizations with no expenses, revenue, government support, website visitors, or free tickets. Far from examining a cross-section of arts nonprofits in the United States, this study is focused on about half of organizations that submitted CDP profiles – meaning they are also located in one of the 12 states (including the District of Columbia) that have active CDP partnerships. Only one of those states (California) is located on the West Coast. None are in the South or Pacific Northwest.</p>
<p>Furthermore, just because such correlations exist in the CDP dataset doesn’t mean donors are making decisions based on the metrics the authors examine. There is no way to know whether foundations in the regions studied were closely following attendance rates at the organizations they funded, to say nothing of website traffic. To be fair, the authors acknowledge most of these problems, and they call for further research to better examine the relationship between organizational performance, fundraising, and donor behavior. That said, drawing firm conclusions from this study is difficult. What does seem clear is that a) foundations in the regions where CDP is used appear to behave differently from corporate and individual donors; and b) that behavior implies they are more likely to decrease their support as an organization builds a larger audience base. Similarly, foundations in those regions are more likely to respond positively to organizations that spend more money on fundraising.</p>
<p><b>What it all means: </b>Given the unique role that foundations play in the nonprofit arts ecosystem as gatekeepers and, oftentimes, thought leaders, this study raises several intriguing questions about the extent to which they actually respond to the metrics of success to which they ask their grantees to adhere. It’s very possible that most funders eschew attendance and website data altogether, and focus on different outcomes that are tied to their own theories of change. It’s also possible (though not likely) that they are easily charmed by development officers and/or fundraising galas. Whatever the case may be, it’s worth noting that their decisions do not align with individual or corporate donors. Perhaps that’s how it should be; perhaps it indicates a flaw in how most foundations decide who to support. Without more research into the questions the authors raise – and more comprehensive datasets with which to analyze them – it’s difficult to know.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
			<wfw:commentRss>https://createquity.com/2017/08/capsule-review-do-donors-care-about-results/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
		<slash:comments>0</slash:comments>
		</item>
		<item>
		<title>Capsule Review: Critical Thinking</title>
		<link>https://createquity.com/2017/07/capsule-review-critical-thinking/</link>
		<comments>https://createquity.com/2017/07/capsule-review-critical-thinking/#respond</comments>
		<pubDate>Mon, 10 Jul 2017 12:00:20 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Talia Gibas]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[Insider]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[arts education]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[capsule review]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[critical thinking]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Crystal Bridges]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[museums]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[visual arts]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://createquity.com/?p=10119</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[How much of students’ critical thinking is impacted by a museum field trip – and how much stems from the arts-based nature of the experience?]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="attachment_10123" style="width: 570px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/c6mvPb"><img decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-10123" class="wp-image-10123" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/7280509460_9f38a9095f_k.jpg" alt="" width="560" height="373" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/7280509460_9f38a9095f_k.jpg 2048w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/7280509460_9f38a9095f_k-300x200.jpg 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/7280509460_9f38a9095f_k-768x512.jpg 768w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/7280509460_9f38a9095f_k-1024x683.jpg 1024w" sizes="(max-width: 560px) 100vw, 560px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-10123" class="wp-caption-text">&#8220;mahatma&#8221; by artist cryptik</p></div>
<p><b>Title: </b>Measuring Critical Thinking: Results from an Art Museum Field Trip Experiment</p>
<p><b>Author(s)</b>: Brian Kisida, Daniel H. Bowen and Jay P. Greene</p>
<p><b>Publisher</b>: Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness</p>
<p><b>Year</b>: 2015</p>
<p><b>URL</b>: <a href="http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/19345747.2015.1086915">http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/19345747.2015.1086915</a></p>
<p><b>Topics</b>: arts education, museums, field trip, visual arts, critical thinking</p>
<p><b>Methods</b>: randomized controlled trial involving 8,000 elementary, middle- and high-school students assigned by lottery to attend a field trip and facilitated tour of the Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art in Bentonville, Arkansas. Researchers collected demographic information on the students and conducted a textual analysis of essays written by the students after the field trip responding to an image of a work of art. The essays were coded using a critical-thinking assessment rubric developed by the US Department of Education.</p>
<p><b>What it says</b>: This study validates and expands upon the results of the authors’ <a href="https://createquity.com/2014/10/capsule-review-the-educational-value-of-field-trips/">2013 Crystal Bridges study</a>. The museum field trip was led by trained museum docent facilitating open-ended, student-led discussion about art work in the collections. Following the field trip, students completed surveys on their demographics, prior art consumption and production, knowledge of art, and attitudes toward cultural institutions. Students were also shown an image of a painting that was not part of the Crystal Bridges collection and given five minutes to write an essay describing what was going on in the painting, and what they saw that led them to that conclusion. In the first semester of the experiment, as discussed in the 2013 study, students were shown a representational work of art. Students participating in the study’s second semester were shown an abstract work of art.</p>
<p>All students assigned to the treatment group demonstrated stronger critical-thinking skills in their essays than those in the control group. However, across the board, some aspects of critical thinking as measured by the seven-section rubric were more evident than others; and measurements were not consistent between student responses to representational and abstract pieces. Specifically, students responding to the representational painting showed many examples of observations and interpretations in their written responses, whereas responses to the abstract piece were heavy on observation and light on interpretation. Instances of “problem finding,” “flexible thinking,” and  “comparisons” were less likely in response to abstract work.</p>
<p>However, as reported in the 2013 study, a relatively modest “dose” of arts education – one visit to the visual arts museum – produced a significant effect in the treatment group. Many of the students had never attended a school-based field trip before, and the authors note that students who reported prior exposure to arts education – including non-visual arts education – displayed stronger critical-thinking outcomes in general than students who reported little or no arts exposure. Female students and students from larger communities also scored higher on the critical-thinking rubric. Interestingly, students attending Title I schools showed significantly higher critical-thinking outcomes than their more affluent counterparts when responding to the representational artwork, but the differences were less pronounced for the groups responding to the abstract work.</p>
<p><b>What I think about it</b>: The 2013 Crystal Bridges was rightly lauded for its scale, clarity, and thoughtfulness. This 2015 follow-up continues in that mold. Randomized controlled trials such as this one are considered a gold standard for research; the high level of inter-rater reliability among the researchers coding the student essays – who were not aware of any student characteristics (including whether they were in the treatment or control group) – leaves little to fault in the study’s design. There are limitations, of course: there is no way to know whether the effects on the treatment group last over time, for example, and whether they would remain consistent in an urban area that afforded residents more cultural opportunities. The difference in student responses to the abstract versus representational works of art also raises questions about the depth of conclusions to be drawn. Students were only given five minutes to write their essays, so the fact that they primarily stuck to observations and interpretations isn’t surprising; nor is it illogical that students working with the abstract piece offered fewer interpretations and more observations about the work. It would be interesting to see how the responses would have evolved if students were given more time to work on them. It would also be useful to know which elements of critical thinking were on display during the treatment group discussions at the museum. According to the authors: “The goal of the museum educators was to facilitate an open-ended, student-centered approach to discuss the works of art, encourage a deep level of engagement, and motivate students to seek out their own unique interpretations.” The extent to which students accomplished this, and the balance of observation versus interpretation in the discussions, may have depended on their abilities to respond to the essay prompt in a short amount of time.</p>
<p>Another question emerges: how much of the impact on students’ critical thinking had to do with the field trip and how much had to do with the arts-based nature of the experience? The authors note that “this research does not establish which components of the art museum experience were essential for increases in critical-thinking skills, or if these same effects could be generated from school-based arts exposure.” I wonder whether there were components that didn’t have to do with the arts at all. If students were guided to discuss a representational photograph, or to observe an environment for a science class, would such observational practice lead to similar results? And how much, if any, of the critical-thinking gains exhibited in this study might transfer over to other activities?</p>
<p><b>What it all means</b>: Not many randomized controlled trials take place in arts education, so this one is heartening; perhaps it will serve as inspiration to other researchers interested not only in the impact of the arts on students, but how critical-thinking skills are cultivated in the first place. Despite its scale, the study leaves several questions unanswered. It does confirm that, in the short term, students who participated in a field trip to the Crystal Bridges Museum were able to respond to works of art in a more robust way than students who did not. As with the first Crystal Bridges study, the fact that this effect is most pronounced for Title I students examining representational work seems worthy of further examination.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
			<wfw:commentRss>https://createquity.com/2017/07/capsule-review-critical-thinking/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
		<slash:comments>0</slash:comments>
		</item>
		<item>
		<title>The State: A Friend Indeed to Artists in Need?</title>
		<link>https://createquity.com/2016/07/the-state-a-friend-indeed-to-artists-in-need/</link>
		<comments>https://createquity.com/2016/07/the-state-a-friend-indeed-to-artists-in-need/#comments</comments>
		<pubDate>Fri, 08 Jul 2016 11:31:16 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Shawn Lent, Michael Feldman, Talia Gibas and Louise Geraghty]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[Analysis]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[arts careers]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[economic disadvantage and the arts]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[government funding]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[individual artists]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[international]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[international arts funding]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[socioeconomic status]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[State sponsorship]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://createquity.com/?p=9169</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[Internationally, governments can play an important role creating occupational equity for the arts - but there’s a catch.]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>From <a href="http://www.culturalpolicies.net/web/azerbaijan.php?aid=21" target="_blank">Baku</a> to <a href="http://www.unesco.org/new/en/unesco/worldwide/africa/central-african-republic/" target="_blank">Bangui</a>, Boston to Bangkok, we need a diverse, equitable world of cultural voices for our times. Createquity imagines that a <a href="https://createquity.com/about/a-healthy-arts-ecosystem/" target="_blank">healthy arts ecosystem</a> is one in which opportunities to make one’s living as an artist are distributed equitably across socioeconomic levels. Unfortunately, that does not seem to be the case in many western countries, where research indicates that people of lesser means are not as equipped to take on <a href="https://createquity.com/2016/06/who-can-afford-to-be-a-starving-artist/" target="_blank">the risk</a> involved in pursuing a career in the arts.</p>
<p>Around the world, we see people facing challenges not only accessing careers as artists, but also sustaining them. <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/culture-professionals-network/2015/jan/12/artists-low-income-international-issues" target="_blank">South Korean artists make 77% and Canadian artists 74%</a> of their respective countries’ average income. In Ireland, <a href="http://ifacca.org/en/news/2016/05/19/visual-artists-ireland-calls-government-immediate/" target="_blank">80% of visual artists</a> who depend on their creative income live in poverty. One survey respondent in that country describes the outlook for artists this way: “The future always looks worse than the past. Economic booms are quite bad for artists, because they <a href="http://www.artscouncil.ie/uploadedFiles/LWCA_Study_-_Final_2010.pdf" target="_blank">can&#8217;t afford to live where they should</a> for their careers. Busts are worse.”</p>
<p>Generally, people born into less affluence have to <a href="http://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/10000-hour-rule-not-real-180952410/?no-ist" target="_blank">work harder</a> to catch up in any field. The Guardian’s Sonia Sodha writes that “we’ll never be able to eliminate the role that good fortune plays, but we need to <a href="http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/may/01/only-successful-people-can-afford-cv-of-failure" target="_blank">do much more to lessen its influence</a> and increase the relationship between effort and success.” What role can government play in lessening the influence of fortune when it comes to supporting artists? A look at several countries gives us some clues.</p>
<div id="attachment_9177" style="width: 460px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/Lt3RA"><img decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-9177" class="wp-image-9177" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/503203452_ffb290fbef_b-1024x683.jpg" alt="Tran Thi Doanh, painter - Photo by Flickr user, Duc" width="450" height="300" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/503203452_ffb290fbef_b.jpg 1024w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/503203452_ffb290fbef_b-300x200.jpg 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/503203452_ffb290fbef_b-768x512.jpg 768w" sizes="(max-width: 450px) 100vw, 450px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-9177" class="wp-caption-text">Tran Thi Doanh, Vietnames painter &#8211; Photo by Flickr user, Duc</p></div>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h2><b>Two Models: National Status vs. Sink or Swim </b></h2>
<p>In some countries, including the United States, being an artist doesn’t necessarily mean having a professional artist career track, especially not in any sort of state-sponsored system. As one national study of artists reported, “some painters interviewed said that <a href="https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/NEA-Research-Report-37.pdf" target="_blank"><i>career</i> was not part of their professional vocabulary</a>; they simply <i>were painters</i>.” In that context, <a href="https://createquity.com/2016/06/who-can-afford-to-be-a-starving-artist/" target="_blank">as we’ve explored</a>, many US-based artists have day jobs and backup plans, and find themselves <a href="http://www.haassr.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/caCrossover.pdf" target="_blank">crossing between nonprofit and commercial sectors</a> in a demanding market economy.</p>
<p>In other parts of the world such as in the former Soviet Union, as scholar Nina Dimitrialdi describes in her 2009 PhD dissertation on challenges faced by US and UK artists, <a href="https://www.zotero.org/groups/createquity/items/collectionKey/GXJVFHWS/itemKey/HV7Q59T8" target="_blank">“artist” was indeed a profession</a> just like any other. An artist in the Russian Federation with “professional” status from the government currently receives compulsory social programs such as insurance covering <a href="http://portal.unesco.org/culture/en/ev.php-URL_ID=33176&amp;URL_DO=DO_TOPIC&amp;URL_SECTION=201.html" target="_blank">illness, housing, maternity, disability, and retirement</a>. Many countries with cultural sectors based on the old Soviet model, such as <a href="http://egyptartsacademy.kenanaonline.com/" target="_blank">Egypt</a>, fully bankroll training programs and manage “card carrying” artists and their benefits through a national union.</p>
<div id="attachment_9170" style="width: 415px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-9170" class=" wp-image-9170" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Screen-Shot-2016-07-04-at-4.21.21-PM.png" alt="Left: Egypt’s High Institute of Ballet, 2013 (conditions under Presidents Mubarak, Mansour and Morsi) | Right: Same facility in 2016 (under President ElSisi) - Images by Shawn Lent and Madga Saleh" width="405" height="401" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Screen-Shot-2016-07-04-at-4.21.21-PM.png 486w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Screen-Shot-2016-07-04-at-4.21.21-PM-150x150.png 150w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Screen-Shot-2016-07-04-at-4.21.21-PM-300x298.png 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Screen-Shot-2016-07-04-at-4.21.21-PM-32x32.png 32w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Screen-Shot-2016-07-04-at-4.21.21-PM-64x64.png 64w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Screen-Shot-2016-07-04-at-4.21.21-PM-96x96.png 96w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Screen-Shot-2016-07-04-at-4.21.21-PM-128x128.png 128w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 405px) 100vw, 405px" /><p id="caption-attachment-9170" class="wp-caption-text">Left: Egypt’s High Institute of Ballet, 2013 (conditions under Presidents Mubarak, Mansour and Morsi) | Right: Same facility in 2016 (under President el-Sisi) &#8211; Images by Shawn Lent and Madga Saleh</p></div>
<p>Whether or not artistry is a formal profession in the eyes of the state, and what states do or don’t do to support that profession, reflects <a href="http://worldcp.org/index.php" target="_blank">different agendas within different political systems</a>. While the <a href="https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/how-the-us-funds-the-arts.pdf" target="_blank">American model mostly distributes public funding for the arts indirectly</a>, via tax deductions for nonprofit organizations and their donors, many other governments provide substantial direct support to individual artists. Increased overall <a href="https://createquity.com/2012/05/is-federal-money-the-best-way-to-fund-the-arts/" target="_blank">government funding for the arts</a> could be an important indicator of potential support for economically disadvantaged artists, but there is an opportunity in cultural policy to assess what funding schemes help bridge wealth gaps in the profession.</p>
<p>Unfortunately, we found existing research on this topic to cover predominantly North American and European countries, with few nationally representative results relating to artists from poorer backgrounds. While it is difficult to get a good read on the situation internationally, in many parts of the world, it does appear that dedicated government support – in the forms of subsidies and other incentives – has opened the artistic profession to more people across social classes.</p>
<div id="attachment_9172" style="width: 443px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/jDn15L" rel="attachment wp-att-9172"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-9172" class="wp-image-9172" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/12237229804_0bee3e60c1_k-1024x768.jpg" alt="Europe Day Slovenia - Photo by Flickr user, Steve" width="433" height="325" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-9172" class="wp-caption-text">Europe Day Slovenia &#8211; Photo by Flickr user, Steve</p></div>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h2><b>Public Policy Can Keep Artists Afloat</b></h2>
<p>We see a number of countries enacting support programs for artists that are tied in with their tradition of centralized social services, supporting the basic needs of all citizens; this could be critical for artists and similar types of workers. As Quartz’s Aimee Groth put it when speaking about entrepreneurs, &#8220;<a href="http://qz.com/455109/entrepreneurs-dont-have-a-special-gene-for-risk-they-come-from-families-with-money/" target="_blank">when basic needs are met, it&#8217;s easier to be creative.</a>&#8221; By giving more of a safety net to artists born with less means, government programs can make it easier for people (artists included) to risk being &#8220;<a href="https://createquity.com/2016/06/who-can-afford-to-be-a-starving-artist/" target="_blank">entrepreneurial</a>.&#8221;</p>
<p><a href="http://portal.unesco.org/culture/en/ev.php-URL_ID=40139&amp;URL_DO=DO_TOPIC&amp;URL_SECTION=201.html" target="_blank">Slovenia</a>, <a href="http://www.taike.fi/documents/10921/0/Heikkinen+26+03.pdf" target="_blank">Finland</a>, <a href="http://www.billboard.com/biz/articles/news/global/1305861/italys-enpals-extends-labels-pensions-deadline" target="_blank">Italy</a> and <a href="http://www.culturalpolicies.net/web/austria.php?aid=514" target="_blank">Austria</a> are a few of the many countries that offer pension and retirement programs to deserving artists as defined by those governments. The South Korean <a href="http://www.koreaherald.com/view.php?ud=20111102000634&amp;mod=skb" target="_blank">Artists Welfare Act</a> extends the country’s employment insurance to 180,000 artists and accident insurance to 57,000 artists. The Danish Arts Foundation’s <a href="http://www.kunst.dk/statens-kunstfond/om-statens-kunstfond/om-haedersydelser/" target="_blank">life-long benefit grants</a> (<i>livsvarige statsydelser</i>) are awarded to state-selected, high-achieving artists in that country. In Thailand artists employed by the Ministry of Culture are <a href="http://portal.unesco.org/culture/en/ev.php-URL_ID=33182&amp;URL_DO=DO_TOPIC&amp;URL_SECTION=201.html" target="_blank">considered civil service officers</a> with the same salary system and benefits, and in Germany, the Artists&#8217; Social Insurance Fund (<a href="http://www.kuenstlersozialkasse.de/" target="_blank"><i>Künstlersozialkasse</i></a> or<i> KSK</i>) has been supporting self-employed artists and journalists since 1983.</p>
<div id="attachment_9182" style="width: 460px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/6x7wS3" rel="attachment wp-att-9182"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-9182" class="wp-image-9182" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/3633869710_6f6561ab2a_z.jpg" alt="Making an appointment with Sabine Schlüter, head of KSK (Künstlersozialkasse) - Photo by Flickr user, Henning Krause" width="450" height="300" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/3633869710_6f6561ab2a_z.jpg 500w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/3633869710_6f6561ab2a_z-300x200.jpg 300w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 450px) 100vw, 450px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-9182" class="wp-caption-text">2009 Making an appointment with Sabine Schlüter, head of KSK (Künstlersozialkasse) &#8211; Photo by Flickr user, Henning Krause</p></div>
<p><b>Estonia</b></p>
<p>Another country advancing its support of artists is <a href="http://www.kul.ee/en/news/artistic-unions-announced-competitions-artists-and-writers-salaries" target="_blank">Estonia</a>, where a select group of artists and writers are offered a €1005 salary per month for two years plus health insurance and a pension plan. According to Indrek Saar, Estonia’s Minister of Culture, “the purpose of [the program] is to offer for a couple of years a possibility to work in peace and social guarantees for the distinguished creative people. <a href="http://www.kul.ee/en/news/artistic-unions-announced-competitions-artists-and-writers-salaries" target="_blank">Economic stability of a creative person</a> gives better preconditions to create a new work of art.” This year Saar announced a <a href="http://www.kul.ee/en/news/minister-culture-signed-agreement-wages-cultural-professionals-2016" target="_blank">13.5% raise to the minimum wage</a> for cultural professionals in that country’s government. This program is quite similar to one in <a href="http://www.konstnarsnamnden.se/default.aspx?id=12154" target="_blank">Sweden</a>, where income guarantees are given to selected artists who have created work considered “<a href="http://www.thelocal.se/20100217/25048" target="_blank">important for Swedish cultural life</a>.”</p>
<p><b>Netherlands</b></p>
<p>The Netherlands has historically been a strong leader in this realm. The Dutch Artists’ Work and Income Scheme Act (<a href="http://wetten.overheid.nl/BWBR0017837/2011-07-01" target="_blank">WWIK</a>), in place from 2005-2012, was the third major artist subsidy program developed for the country. WWIK provided financial support (<a href="http://www.artscouncil.ie/uploadedFiles/LWCA_Study_-_Final_2010.pdf" target="_blank">70-125% of the guaranteed minimum income</a>) for artists with a low income for a maximum of 48 months over 10 years to cover the start-up period of their professional arts career. Dutch artists also received extensions in the availability of unemployment benefits (4 years rather than 6 months).</p>
<p>While that program did not track impact for artists from financial disadvantage, another example from the Dutch attempted to connect cause and effect. From the 1960s-80s, the Netherlands provided temporary assistance to low-income visual artists that allowed those artists to sell their work directly to local governments as a supplement to income. The number of participating <a href="https://www.zotero.org/groups/createquity/items/collectionKey/GXJVFHWS/itemKey/IG75AKWX" target="_blank">artists increased from 200 in 1960 to 3800 in 1983</a>. During the same period, the growth rate of student enrollment in fine arts departments at Dutch academies was 60% higher than the average growth rate for technical and vocational training in other fields.</p>
<div id="attachment_9173" style="width: 473px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/wwCDA" rel="attachment wp-att-9173"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-9173" class=" wp-image-9173" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/345471524_1236657796_b-1024x686.jpg" alt="Members of Ethiopia's Ras Theatre group dance and play as they wait for Uganda's President Yoweri Museveni at Bole Airport, Addis Ababa - Photo by Flickr user, Andrew Heavens" width="463" height="310" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/345471524_1236657796_b.jpg 1024w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/345471524_1236657796_b-300x201.jpg 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/345471524_1236657796_b-768x515.jpg 768w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 463px) 100vw, 463px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-9173" class="wp-caption-text">Members of Ethiopia&#8217;s Ras Theatre group dance and play as they wait for Uganda&#8217;s President Yoweri Museveni at Bole Airport, Addis Ababa &#8211; Photo by Flickr user, Andrew Heavens</p></div>
<h2></h2>
<h2><b>The Warning: Selling Out (or Buying In) for Survival</b></h2>
<p>Governments sponsor artists for a complex set of purposes: <a href="http://mkrf.ru/press-tsentr/novosti/ministerstvo/v-krymu-prokhodit-zasedanie-koordinatsionnogo-soveta-po-kulture-pri-minkultury-r" target="_blank">cultural tourism</a> like the kind Russia is planning in occupied Crimea; <a href="http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/roads/2015/05/cuba_s_rap_agency_the_cuban_hip_hop_community_s_awkward_relationship_with.html" target="_blank">income generation</a> or nationalism such as with the <a href="http://www.ecured.cu/Agencia_Cubana_de_Rap" target="_blank">Agencia Cubana de Rap</a> in Cuba; <a href="http://ifacca.org/en/news/2015/03/16/culture-minister-acts-protect-national-image/" target="_blank">protecting the national image</a> like in Vietnam; “<a href="http://worldcp.org/canada.php?aid=21" target="_blank">preserving the country&#8217;s national cultural assets</a> for the benefit of all citizens and future generations” including aboriginal arts like in Canada; <a href="http://www.mc.gov.md/en/content/minister-culture-had-meeting-ambassador-republic-china-republic-moldova" target="_blank">binational collaboration</a> such as that of China-Moldova; cultural diplomacy, placemaking, or improving public morale. Generally speaking, state-sponsored artists are expected to adhere to policies that align with national interests.</p>
<div id="attachment_9179" style="width: 460px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/h1LEbQ" rel="attachment wp-att-9179"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-9179" class=" wp-image-9179" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/10510421676_b0057b9530_z.jpg" alt="2013 Venice Biennale / Maldives Pavilion - Photo by Flickr user, Emergency Room Thierry" width="450" height="300" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/10510421676_b0057b9530_z.jpg 640w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/10510421676_b0057b9530_z-300x200.jpg 300w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 450px) 100vw, 450px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-9179" class="wp-caption-text">2013 Venice Biennale / Maldives Pavilion &#8211; Photo by Flickr user, Emergency Room Thierry</p></div>
<p>Before we all make a rush on the Dutch consulate or start demanding new state-sponsored artist programs in our respective countries – quite the issue to float in our current political climate – it&#8217;s worth considering the pitfalls that can come with increased government involvement in the arts.</p>
<ul>
<li><b>Threats to Freedom of Speech: </b>Several of the programs mentioned above are or were careful to allow artistic freedom. The Netherlands supported the artists participating in its assistance programs regardless of the style or content of the work they produced. In Estonia, Minister Saar explains that artists receiving the government salaries are “still <a href="http://www.kul.ee/en/news/artistic-unions-announced-competitions-artists-and-writers-salaries" target="_blank">free in their creative work</a>; the only requirement for the creative person is the commitment to one’s creative work.” Unfortunately, such freedoms are the exception rather than the rule. Many countries, such as <a href="http://worldcp.org/zimbabwe.php?aid=33" target="_blank">Zimbabwe</a>, have a national agency for censorship. While increased government support for artists can result in great technical rigor in the respective art forms, like in Russian ballet, it can also mean stringent restrictions on artistic expression and a high level of government interference. In 1980, UNESCO recommended governments “determine those remunerative jobs which might be confided to artists <a href="http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0011/001114/111428mo.pdf" target="_blank">without restricting their creativity, their vocation and their freedom of expression and communication</a>.” Russia may recognize artistry as a “profession,” but its track record with creative expression is abysmal; the organization Freemuse registered 32 <a href="http://artsfreedom.org/?p=10834" target="_blank">attacks on artistic freedom</a> in that country (such as censorship, imprisonment, physical attack, and death) in 2015 alone.</li>
<li><b>Questions of Scale and Dysfunction: </b>Government funding artists doesn’t automatically result in a net benefit for all individual artists, let alone poor artists. Many of the programs we came across focused on a relatively small number of superstars. Can any of these programs run at the scale needed to address the flaws in our arts ecology? And at what point might increased scale mean increased risk of corruption? Would an international scheme across the sector be more effective than relying on individual polities?</li>
<li><b>Risk of Perpetuating Cultural Inequities and the Residual Effects of Colonialism</b>: We have been examining government programs from the perspective of reducing socioeconomic inequality in the arts ecosystem, but in fact artists who are LGBTQ, with disabilities, from marginalized racial or religious groups, or political opposition may be just as likely to be excluded from government programs in many countries. With decision-making about which artists to cultivate via government sponsored programs so centralized, states have few incentives to include groups that may be at odds with perceived government interests.</li>
<li><b>Risk of Servile Labor:</b> Similar concerns apply to arts disciplines and new forms of self-expression. If you pursue a career as a painter of socialist realism art because the government only supports and allows that form of art, then there are fewer opportunities for you to express yourself and for audiences to gain benefits from a variety of artistic expressions. Artists in North Korea have been exported to <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/26/arts/design/cambodias-new-angkor-museum-created-by-a-north-korean-art-factory.html?_r=0" target="_blank">execute massive arts projects in countries such as Cambodia</a>, hired as employees to earn hard currency for the State.</li>
<li><b>Lack of Cultural Variety</b>: Even when a government’s intentions are pure, it is not clear that placing decisions about artists’ careers in the hands of bureaucrats leads to the best possible mix of cultural products and experiences. Generous benefits for artists in all likelihood means a limit on the number of artists who can access those benefits, which may mean that the people left out have even fewer opportunities to have a public creative identity and get paid for it. For all its issues, the <a href="http://portal.unesco.org/culture/en/ev.php-URL_ID=33186&amp;URL_DO=DO_TOPIC&amp;URL_SECTION=201.html" target="_blank">United States’s market approach</a> is rarely criticized for yielding a boring, homogeneous mix of work.</li>
</ul>
<div id="attachment_9178" style="width: 464px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/5UVLmV" rel="attachment wp-att-9178"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-9178" class=" wp-image-9178" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/3224375029_72275d1709_o.jpg" alt="National Ballet of China 'Raise the Red Lantern' - Photo by Flickr user, Jesse Clockwork" width="454" height="301" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/3224375029_72275d1709_o.jpg 652w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/3224375029_72275d1709_o-300x199.jpg 300w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 454px) 100vw, 454px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-9178" class="wp-caption-text">National Ballet of China &#8216;Raise the Red Lantern&#8217; &#8211; Photo by Flickr user, Jesse Clockwork</p></div>
<p>Government policies can make it possible for artists to pursue better, more dignified careers, but there is no such thing as a free lunch. As we move forward in addressing the questions of support and equal opportunity in arts careers, we must be conscious of the tradeoffs inherent in systems that rely on more overt government or other patronage of the arts.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p><strong><em>In the<a href="https://createquity.com/2016/08/createquity-podcast-series-2-the-cost-of-being-creative/" target="_blank"> latest Createquity podcast series</a>, Createquity and Fractured Atlas team members illuminate the major factors that contribute to artists (or prevent artists from) establishing successful careers. We also focus on some of the tools Fractured Atlas has developed to support artists, with the larger goal of helping create a more navigable and equitable ecosystem for professional artists.</em></strong></p>
<p><em>Cover image: “<a class="external" href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/pixiduc/sets/72157656768248371" target="_blank">Radical &#8211; Avant la Tempête @ EDLD 2015</a>,” courtesy of Flickr user, Duc, via Flickr Creative Commons license. </em></p>
]]></content:encoded>
			<wfw:commentRss>https://createquity.com/2016/07/the-state-a-friend-indeed-to-artists-in-need/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
		<slash:comments>1</slash:comments>
			<dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Feldman]]></dc:creator>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Talia Gibas]]></dc:creator>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Louise Geraghty]]></dc:creator>
	</item>
		<item>
		<title>Who Can Afford to Be A Starving Artist?</title>
		<link>https://createquity.com/2016/06/who-can-afford-to-be-a-starving-artist/</link>
		<comments>https://createquity.com/2016/06/who-can-afford-to-be-a-starving-artist/#comments</comments>
		<pubDate>Tue, 14 Jun 2016 12:08:10 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Shawn Lent, Louise Geraghty, Michael Feldman, Talia Gibas and Ian David Moss]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[Features]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[arts careers]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[disparities of access]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[economic disadvantage and the arts]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[individual artists]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[risk tolerance]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Thiel Fellowship]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://createquity.com/?p=9111</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[The key to success might be risk tolerance, not talent.]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Take a minute and picture a world in which every adult on the planet is a full-time, professional artist. Arts funding and education are abundant and folks spend their days in the studios, galleries, stages, pages, screens, and streets creating in collaborative groups or in Zen-like isolation. Would that be a good world to live in? To some readers, it probably sounds utopian. But spend a little more time with that vision, and dilemmas quickly arise.</p>
<p>Who will take care of these artist-citizens when they get sick or injured? Who will grow food and repair buildings? Who will mediate disputes? Perhaps in a radical shift toward interdisciplinary living, these functions will be considered new artforms. Perhaps the growth of artificial intelligence will, in fact, have rendered these functions obsolete, freeing people to focus on artistic pursuits if they wanted. In our 21st century reality, though, not everyone who envisions an arts career can follow through on that dream. The option to make one’s living as a pro artist is bestowed upon a small portion of the people who desire it.</p>
<p>Which begs the question: who should those people be?</p>
<div id="attachment_9114" style="width: 444px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/5GPqLT"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-9114" class="wp-image-9114" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/3087340515_5d7fbc28ac_o.jpg" alt="Photo by Flickr user, hollyannephotog7 https://flic.kr/p/5GPqLT " width="434" height="289" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/3087340515_5d7fbc28ac_o.jpg 774w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/3087340515_5d7fbc28ac_o-300x200.jpg 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/3087340515_5d7fbc28ac_o-768x511.jpg 768w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 434px) 100vw, 434px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-9114" class="wp-caption-text">Photo by Flickr user, hollyannephotog7</p></div>
<p><a href="https://createquity.com/about/a-healthy-arts-ecosystem/">As we at Createquity perceive it</a>, they should be the artists whose work offers the greatest benefit to others. That can mean engaging an unusually large audience. It can mean winning disproportionate respect from experts. It can mean adding something unique to the cultural diet of humanity. Or it can mean improving lives in other concrete and meaningful ways.</p>
<p>Those criteria should have little, if anything, to do with an artist&#8217;s family tax bracket. And yet we see troubling signs that socioeconomic status does correlate with access to a professional arts career. Logically, it makes sense: if an occupation is attractive but probably low-paying, and then there are socioeconomic inequalities in the road to becoming a professional, inevitably that line of work would beckon more people from affluent backgrounds.</p>
<p>Empirically, reliable data is hard to come by, but what we have found tends to support the suspicion. One U.K. study finds that artists there are <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2015/nov/23/middle-class-people-dominate-arts-survey-finds" target="_blank">predominantly middle class</a>, and a U.S. report declared that average <a href="http://www.bls.gov/nls/nlsy79.htm" target="_blank">household income during the childhood of artists</a> (in 1979) was the same as those who went on to become chief executives, general managers, and engineers—above the <a href="http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/03/18/289013884/who-had-richer-parents-doctors-or-arists">60th percentile</a> of family income. Our own analysis of the 2008 Survey of Public Participation in the Arts via the <a href="http://www.icpsr.umich.edu/icpsrweb/NADAC/" target="_blank">National Archive of Data on Arts &amp; Culture</a> reveals that professionals in &#8220;Arts, design, entertainment, sports, and media occupations&#8221; were about 60% more likely than average to have a father who attended at least some college (55.9% vs. 34.5%), and 70% more likely to have a mother who attended college (55.9% vs. 32.6%). That is the most extreme skew of any of 23 occupation categories for mother&#8217;s education; for fathers, it&#8217;s exceeded only by mathematics and computer science occupations.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<div id="attachment_9113" style="width: 460px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/7A3HwS"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-9113" class="wp-image-9113" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/4323431410_2225be31ba_b-1024x662.jpg" alt="Artist by Flickr user, Esther Simpson https://flic.kr/p/7A3HwS " width="450" height="291" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/4323431410_2225be31ba_b.jpg 1024w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/4323431410_2225be31ba_b-300x194.jpg 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/4323431410_2225be31ba_b-768x497.jpg 768w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 450px) 100vw, 450px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-9113" class="wp-caption-text">Artist by Flickr user, Esther Simpson</p></div>
<p>What’s behind these trends? Last month, our article on <a href="https://createquity.com/2016/05/the-bfas-dance-with-inequality/" target="_blank">The BFA&#8217;s Dance with Inequality</a> explored whether the cost of an arts agree poses a barrier to individuals in the U.S. from financially disadvantaged backgrounds who may otherwise wish to pursue a career in the arts. The short answer is that it doesn’t – in fact, the vast majority of working artists in this country do not have arts degrees, although the importance of such a credential to an arts career does vary widely by artistic discipline and goals.</p>
<p>What about risk? Could poorer individuals be shying away from becoming artists because of what might happen if it doesn’t work out? Are the risks associated with an arts career disproportionately discouraging to economically disadvantaged individuals? Are there other sectors we can learn from?</p>
<p>Here’s what we do know about pursuing a career in the arts.</p>
<ul>
<li><b>The notion of “the day job” is very real.</b> Artists <a href="http://faos.ku.dk/pdf/undervisning_og_arrangementer/2010/ARTISTS__CAREERS_191010.pdf#17" target="_blank">tend to have other work to draw from </a>to earn income. The day-job phenomenon is especially true for artists who support single-income households. For example, Australian artists who don’t rely on the income from a partner spend <a href="http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/09548963.2011.540809" target="_blank">more time on non-arts work</a>.</li>
</ul>
<ul>
<li><b>Many artists are making backup plans.</b> Although artists are possibly go-getters by getting out into the field sooner than other professionals (with <a href="http://faos.ku.dk/pdf/undervisning_og_arrangementer/2010/ARTISTS__CAREERS_191010.pdf#21" target="_blank">fewer total years of education</a>), nearly half of them in the U.S., according to BFAMFAPhD’s <a href="http://bfamfaphd.com/#artists-report-back" target="_blank">“Artists Report Back,”</a> built a safety net by <a href="http://temporaryartreview.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/bfamfaphd_artistsreportback2014.pdf" target="_blank">majoring in another subject</a>. Arts students also pick up more <a href="https://www.zotero.org/groups/createquity/items/collectionKey/GXJVFHWS/itemKey/4FX424BC" target="_blank">minors and teaching certificates</a> as part of their “backup” planning – one way to try to minimize the risk inherent in their choices.</li>
</ul>
<ul>
<li><b>The artist’s path is fraught with risk. </b>The professional arts career has a <a href="https://www.zotero.org/groups/createquity/items/collectionKey/GXJVFHWS/itemKey/THCRI8DH" target="_blank">long gestation period with high opportunity costs</a>. Artists face <a href="https://www.zotero.org/groups/createquity/items/collectionKey/GXJVFHWS/itemKey/THCRI8DH" target="_blank">greater variability in their earnings</a> than those working in other fields and are <a href="http://faos.ku.dk/pdf/undervisning_og_arrangementer/2010/ARTISTS__CAREERS_191010.pdf#25" target="_blank">five times more likely to be self-employed</a>. Some have hypothesized that this nature of the arts <a href="http://www.americansforthearts.org/by-program/reports-and-data/legislation-policy/naappd/risk-uncertainty-and-the-performing-arts" target="_blank">draws more risk-seeking individuals</a> than the general labor market.</li>
</ul>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h2><b>Inequality Across Sister Sectors<br />
</b></h2>
<p>In many ways, artists have a lot in common with tech entrepreneurs. The early (and sometimes not so early) stages of their careers could be likened to the startup phase of companies, in which Mark Zuckerberg hopefuls pull ramen-fueled all-nighters for uncertain, uneven remuneration. Working artists <a href="https://www.zotero.org/groups/createquity/items/collectionKey/GXJVFHWS/itemKey/THCRI8DH">interact with labor markets </a>in ways that could be compared to small firms. The two fields have common controversies: for tech entrepreneurs the necessity of a college degree has likewise been <a href="http://www.pbs.org/newshour/making-sense/the-pernicious-myth-that-you-d/" target="_blank">called into question</a>. There’s even a debt-free, direct path for emerging tech stars from all types of socioeconomic backgrounds. A prime example is the <a href="http://thielfellowship.org/about/" target="_blank">Thiel Fellowship</a>; following in the footsteps of other dropouts such as Bill Gates, young tech entrepreneurs are receiving $100,000 if they <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/16/business/the-thiel-fellows-forgoing-college-to-pursue-dreams.html?_r=0" target="_blank">leave or put off college</a> to pursue their own Thiel projects.</p>
<div id="attachment_9119" style="width: 508px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="http://bit.ly/22PHrxC" rel="attachment wp-att-9119"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-9119" class=" wp-image-9119" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/2fe045f.jpg" alt="Photo by ThielFellowship.org as well as LinkedIn user, Mike Olson " width="498" height="233" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/2fe045f.jpg 1200w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/2fe045f-300x140.jpg 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/2fe045f-768x359.jpg 768w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/2fe045f-1024x479.jpg 1024w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 498px) 100vw, 498px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-9119" class="wp-caption-text">Photo by ThielFellowship.org as well as LinkedIn user, Mike Olson</p></div>
<p>Unfortunately, in both fields, the risks involved in developing a career seemingly correlate with the underrepresentation of low-SES professionals. According to one U.S. survey, entrepreneurs <a href="https://www.zotero.org/groups/createquity/items/collectionKey/GXJVFHWS/itemKey/UVC245X6" target="_blank">skew toward affluence</a>; by another account, tech entrepreneurs come <a href="http://www.kauffman.org/~/media/kauffman_org/research%20reports%20and%20covers/2009/07/anatomy_of_entre_071309_final.pdf" target="_blank">mostly from middle-class backgrounds</a>. The Global Entrepreneurship Monitor found that “<a href="http://www.gemconsortium.org/report" target="_blank">more than 80% of funding</a> for new enterprises comes from personal savings, family and friends.”</p>
<p>We don’t know whether tech entrepreneurs try to mitigate the risks of their careers, but it seems like artists do. A question lingers: if artists can and do create backup plans and hold day jobs to lower their personal risk, how do we explain why aren&#8217;t there more low-SES professional artists? Perhaps it’s related to <a href="https://www.zotero.org/groups/createquity/items/collectionKey/GXJVFHWS/itemKey/UVC245X6" target="_blank">social and human capital</a>. In order to be successful, artists need to be able to commit uncompensated time to a passion project, particularly over an extended period. They need to spend thousands of hours in training/practice, which are thousands of hours that they’re not earning a living.</p>
<p>No matter what entrepreneurial capacities we <a href="http://ssir.org/articles/entry/venture_philanthropy_for_the_arts_for_innovation" target="_blank">teach, push and support</a> to prepare emerging artists for this uncertain economy, a person’s financial circumstances could matter quite a bit. Resources depend, at least partly, on a stable asset base, and the limited resources of low-SES populations might<a href="http://www.businessinsider.com/privilege-inequality-silicon-valley-2016-1" target="_blank"> impact their ability to grow their new businesses</a> and arts careers, demanding greater risk-taking. The National Bureau of Economic Research recently provided indications that <a href="http://www.nber.org/papers/w21332" target="_blank">risk tolerance relates much more to circumstances (behavior in relationship to environment) than to personality</a>, pointing to evidence that individuals from poorer backgrounds have lower risk tolerance.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h2><b>Risking It All, for What?</b></h2>
<p>Like tech entrepreneurship, the arts are among the world’s <a href="https://createquity.com/2013/10/artists-not-alone-in-steep-climb-to-the-top/" target="_blank">“winner-take-all” industries</a>; with the exception of a handful of superstars, most of the pack will struggle mightily toward public acclaim and financial stability. The risk artists face, though, is on another level: even when successful in establishing a career at all, they experience the <a href="http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/03/18/289013884/who-had-richer-parents-doctors-or-arists" target="_blank">biggest drop between income during childhood and income during adulthood</a> among the 31 careers in the National Longitudinal Survey. Researcher Pierre-Michel Menger <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/223516.pdf?seq=1#page_scan_tab_contents" target="_blank">reports</a> in the 1999 <i>Annual Review of Sociology</i> that &#8220;the skewed distribution of artists income is strongly biased to the lower end of the range.&#8221; In Canada, arts managers, directors, coordinators and government cultural workers have <a href="http://www.cbc.ca/beta/arts/who-makes-up-the-1-in-the-arts-it-s-the-bureaucrats-1.3607715" target="_blank">higher and rising salaries</a> compared to the art-makers themselves, who in the U.S. are more likely than non-artist and technical professionals to live below the poverty line (<a href="http://faos.ku.dk/pdf/undervisning_og_arrangementer/2010/ARTISTS__CAREERS_191010.pdf#25" target="_blank">6.9 percent vs. 4.2 percent</a> <a href="http://faos.ku.dk/pdf/undervisning_og_arrangementer/2010/ARTISTS__CAREERS_191010.pdf" target="_blank">according to data from the 2000 US Census</a>).</p>
<p>Is it just the dream of fame and fortune that compels aspiring artists to take such gambles? Or is it expression and societal contribution? Financial benefit, interestingly, does not appear to be much of a motivator for good work. According to Menger, professional artists feel “zero or negative correlation between <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/223516.pdf?seq=1#page_scan_tab_contents" target="_blank">effort and earnings</a>.” In a recent London study of cultural industry professionals, <a href="http://www.createlondon.org/panic/survey/" target="_blank">88% reported that they have worked for free</a>; individuals from low-SES backgrounds may not always have that luxury. Indeed, risk aversion might be a reason less affluent individuals in the United Kingdom are <a href="https://createquity.com/2016/03/taking-art-into-their-own-hands/" target="_blank">more likely to participate in the arts informally</a>.</p>
<div id="attachment_9115" style="width: 414px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/9gug6Q" rel="attachment wp-att-9115"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-9115" class="wp-image-9115" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/5426115518_00040f1809_b.jpg" alt="Photo by Flickr user, Samira https://flic.kr/p/9gug6Q " width="404" height="343" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/5426115518_00040f1809_b.jpg 1024w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/5426115518_00040f1809_b-300x255.jpg 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/5426115518_00040f1809_b-768x653.jpg 768w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 404px) 100vw, 404px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-9115" class="wp-caption-text">Photo by Flickr user, Samira</p></div>
<h2><b>Looking Ahead<br />
</b></h2>
<p>While we have yet to find solid evidence that risk dissuades individuals from economically disadvantaged backgrounds from pursuing arts careers, we know that if the arts and entrepreneurship remain enclaves for the privileged, we will all be the poorer for it. As much as our cultural and technological palettes have been enhanced by the likes of Nina Simone, Mark Rothko, Steve Jobs, J.K. Rowling, and <em>Hamilton</em>&#8216;s Anthony Ramos, they shouldn&#8217;t be the exception that proves the rule.</p>
<p>One potentially promising area of investigation would be to examine alternate systems that could better support such professionals by decoupling success from an inequitable distribution of risk. Do we need more targeted support for less affluent artists? Germany, France, and Holland have been experimenting with social welfare programs for artists. The government of Sweden is offering lifetime pensions. With a more equitable socioeconomic grounding, the issue of risk for artists (as well as for tech entrepreneurs) might become moot. In our final article of this current series, we’ll explore that topic in greater depth.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p><em><strong>In the <a href="https://createquity.com/2016/08/createquity-podcast-series-2-the-cost-of-being-creative/" target="_blank">latest Createquity podcast series</a>, Createquity and Fractured Atlas team members illuminate the major factors that contribute to artists (or prevent artists from) establishing successful careers. We also focus on some of the tools Fractured Atlas has developed to support artists, with the larger goal of helping create a more navigable and equitable ecosystem for professional artists. </strong></em></p>
<p><em>Cover image: “<a class="external" href="https://flic.kr/p/mSvvkk" target="_blank">Semana Alagoana de Hip Hop</a>,” courtesy of Coletivo Popfuzz via Flickr Creative Commons license. </em></p>
]]></content:encoded>
			<wfw:commentRss>https://createquity.com/2016/06/who-can-afford-to-be-a-starving-artist/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
		<slash:comments>5</slash:comments>
			<dc:creator><![CDATA[Louise Geraghty]]></dc:creator>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Feldman]]></dc:creator>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Talia Gibas]]></dc:creator>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Ian David Moss]]></dc:creator>
	</item>
		<item>
		<title>The BFA&#8217;s Dance With Inequality</title>
		<link>https://createquity.com/2016/05/the-bfas-dance-with-inequality/</link>
		<comments>https://createquity.com/2016/05/the-bfas-dance-with-inequality/#comments</comments>
		<pubDate>Wed, 25 May 2016 15:06:01 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Shawn Lent, Louise Geraghty, Michael Feldman and Talia Gibas]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[Analysis]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[arts careers]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[arts education]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[BFAMFAPhD]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[debt]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[disparities of access]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[economic disadvantage and the arts]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[higher education]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[individual artists]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[SNAAP]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://createquity.com/?p=9054</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[Most arts majors come from money. Most artists didn’t major in the arts. What does that say about the sector?]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>‘Tis joyful commencement season. If you took home a diploma for a four-year degree in the visual or performing arts last weekend, you’re not alone: in the U.S., more than <a href="http://bfamfaphd.com/projects/art-degrees-per-year/">91,000</a> college graduates are venturing out into the world with BFAs or their equivalent in hand. They are more likely to be from <a href="http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/07/college-major-rich-families-liberal-arts/397439/">upper and middle class households</a> than grads from other majors, with an average family income of <a href="http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/07/college-major-rich-families-liberal-arts/397439/">$94,381</a>. Only about <a href="http://temporaryartreview.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/bfamfaphd_artistsreportback2014.pdf">10%</a> of them, if one report is to be believed, will actually become full-time professional artists.</p>
<p>In “the real world,” 84% of working artists—defined by BFAMFAPhD&#8217;s <a href="http://snaap.indiana.edu/databrief/vol3no2.html">controversial</a> <a href="http://bfamfaphd.com/#artists-report-back">&#8220;Artists Report Back&#8221; study</a> as people who make their primary living from their artwork—do not have degrees in the arts, and 40% have no college degree at all. (It&#8217;s important to note that due to data limitations, these figures <a href="https://createquity.com/2016/05/capsule-review-artists-report-back/">exclude artists with master&#8217;s degrees or beyond in any field</a>; however, the number of artists affected is relatively small.) If arts training programs continue to <a href="http://www.artsindexusa.org/2016-national-arts-index">climb in popularity</a> while budding artists from less affluence are deciding against studying the arts in college, does that mean the college-to-career trajectory is a myth? Has the arts degree become a luxury, or are artists from less advantaged backgrounds missing out on something?</p>
<p><a href="http://temporaryartreview.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/bfamfaphd_artistsreportback2014.pdf" rel="attachment wp-att-9056"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="aligncenter wp-image-9056 " src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/untitled-presentation-1-1024x870.png" alt="Graphic by Shawn Lent for Createquity. Source: Artists Report Back" width="470" height="400" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/untitled-presentation-1-1024x870.png 1024w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/untitled-presentation-1-300x255.png 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/untitled-presentation-1-768x653.png 768w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/untitled-presentation-1.png 1200w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 470px) 100vw, 470px" /></a></p>
<p style="text-align: center;">Graphic by Shawn Lent for Createquity. Source: <a href="http://temporaryartreview.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/bfamfaphd_artistsreportback2014.pdf">Artists Report Back</a></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h3><b>An Incubator of Artistry or a Waste of Precious Prime Time?</b></h3>
<p>What can we make of the implication that higher education is not the golden ticket to creating or performing art for a living? It would be overstepping to say that arts degree programs provide students with no value at all: for one thing, they offer important time to refine one’s craft within a <a href="http://snaap.indiana.edu/pdf/2014/SNAAP_AR_2014.pdf">supportive but highly disciplined and similarly-skilled</a> community of peers, critical mentors, and potential networks. Such credentials can serve as a signal of high artistic quality and capacity, a prerequisite for certain grant funding. We should note, though, that artists <a href="http://www.haassr.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/caCrossover.pdf">move freely between the nonprofit and commercial sectors</a> in their pursuit of paid work and the value of a degree likely varies by context. It looks like a person doesn&#8217;t necessarily need a BFA or MFA to become a professional artist, but the degree could help an artist reach a higher level of industry success or <a href="http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/09548963.2011.540809#.V0E0OZMrKT8">make a full-time living as an artist</a>.</p>
<p>At the same time, arts students may not have this expectation of working as artists. Across the board, most graduates (<a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2013/05/20/only-27-percent-of-college-grads-have-a-job-related-to-their-major/">73%</a>) work in a field outside their major. Arts students, in particular, might be prepared to thrive in other sectors, and they seem fine by that; the ongoing Strategic National Arts Alumni Project survey (which likewise has its <a href="https://createquity.com/2013/01/strategic-national-arts-alumni-project-the-condensed-version/">limitations</a>) finds that arts graduates are generally satisfied with their experiences and <a href="http://snaap.indiana.edu/pdf/2012/2012_Annual_Report.pdf">would do it again if they had the chance</a>.</p>
<div id="attachment_9071" style="width: 410px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-9071" class="wp-image-9071" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Undergrads2016-1-e1464144049314.jpg" alt="B.A. and Arts Double-Majors at Commencement 2016, UMD School of Theatre Dance and Performance Studies | Photo by Karen Kohn Bradley" width="400" height="328" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Undergrads2016-1-e1464144049314.jpg 912w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Undergrads2016-1-e1464144049314-300x246.jpg 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Undergrads2016-1-e1464144049314-768x630.jpg 768w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 400px) 100vw, 400px" /><p id="caption-attachment-9071" class="wp-caption-text">B.A. and Arts Double-Majors at Commencement 2016, UMD School of Theatre Dance and Performance Studies | Photo by Karen Kohn Bradley</p></div>
<p>For pro artists, the necessity or desirability of arts degrees may vary considerably by discipline. Although full-time symphony orchestra musicians are selected by audition, it is <a href="http://www.concertgoersguide.org/backstage/path.php">hard to find one these days without a degree in music</a>. On the other hand, from the Oregon Ballet to Bally’s <i>Jubilee</i>, <a href="http://dpeaflcio.org/professionals/professionals-in-the-workplace/professional-performers/">dance</a> artists often delay or skip college because of the early <a href="http://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2014/03/a-dancer-dies-twice-the-unique-sad-challenge-of-retiring-from-ballet/284187/">retirement</a> <a href="http://www.cpanda.org/data/a00191/changes.pdf">age</a> in most dance forms (<a href="http://dpeaflcio.org/professionals/professionals-in-the-workplace/professional-performers/">90.5% of working dancers and choreographers</a> are under age 40, compared to 39.6% of working musicians). Examples like these leave arts degree programs vulnerable to the charge that they are building up a profession (academia) that <a href="http://electricliterature.com/how-the-mfa-glut-is-a-disservice-to-students-teachers-and-writers/">isn&#8217;t necessarily serving artists</a>. Sarah Anne Austin <a href="https://www.danceusa.org/ejournal/2015/03/02/is-american-modern-dance-a-pyramid-scheme">questions</a>, “If opportunities in American modern dance are disappearing, and if being a tenured faculty member at a university is the only stable job available for dancers and choreographers, and having this job depends on being able to attract students… does this make American modern dance a pyramid scheme?”</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h3><b>One Option in a Long Line of Pricey Career Strategies?</b></h3>
<p>Such questions wouldn’t be so charged were it not for the very real concern that arts degrees perpetuate inequality in the sector. Professional artistry has a lengthy and complex gestation period that is slammed with socioeconomic obstacles. Factors that may make, or break, one’s professional success as an artist include personal <a href="http://www.createlondon.org/panic/survey/">networks</a>, the prestige of the teacher, portfolio materials, membership in a <a href="http://dpeaflcio.org/professionals/professionals-in-the-workplace/professional-performers/">union</a>/guild, affordable housing in a city with available arts jobs, and a myriad of other opportunities such as showcases, apprenticeships and <a href="http://snaap.indiana.edu/pdf/SNAAP15/SNAAP_Special_Report_2015.pdf">internships</a>.</p>
<p><a href="http://www.playbill.com/article/schools-of-the-stars-where-hamilton-cast-and-creators-went-to-college-com-355907" rel="attachment wp-att-9059"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="aligncenter wp-image-9059" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/untitled-presentation-2-1024x870.png" alt="untitled-presentation (2)" width="492" height="418" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/untitled-presentation-2-1024x870.png 1024w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/untitled-presentation-2-300x255.png 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/untitled-presentation-2-768x653.png 768w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/untitled-presentation-2.png 1200w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 492px) 100vw, 492px" /></a></p>
<p style="text-align: center;">Graphic by Shawn Lent for Createquity. Source: <a href="http://www.playbill.com/article/schools-of-the-stars-where-hamilton-cast-and-creators-went-to-college-com-355907">Playbill</a></p>
<p>Like aspiring athletes, emerging professional artists benefit from<a href="http://barryoreck.com/articles_papers/ArtisticTalentDevelopment.pdf"> school and community members</a> who identify and develop their interest, regular and rigorous private lessons, and pre-professional training. These present quite the financial hurdle for families: a recent calculation estimates that it takes <a href="http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/high-price-of-ballet-diversity-misty-copeland/">$100,000 to raise a professional ballerina</a>. Against this backdrop, the cost of college may only exacerbate what is already a yawning opportunity gap.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h3><b>The Greatest Risk or the Great Arts Equalizer?</b></h3>
<p>We may not know definitively whether arts degrees provide added value to aspiring artists, but we do know that they pose quite a bit of risk, particularly for artists coming from low socioeconomic status (SES). Although artists with bachelor’s degrees in any major <a href="http://goo.gl/N2AYyx">earn more</a> than artists who went pro after high school, new BFA holders quickly face the reality that artists experience <a href="http://faos.ku.dk/pdf/undervisning_og_arrangementer/2010/ARTISTS__CAREERS_191010.pdf">lower returns</a> to formal education than they would in other professions. Anywhere from 10-20% of artists with bachelor’s degrees <a href="http://snaap.indiana.edu/snaapshot/#debt">report a “major impact” on their career decisions</a> due to debt from higher education; this <a href="http://www.wsj.com/news/interactive/BORROW021620130216?ref=SB10001424127887324432004578306610055834952">debt load</a> comes on top of a heavy <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/223516.pdf?seq=1#page_scan_tab_contents">earnings penalty</a> across the board for artists (<a href="http://faos.ku.dk/pdf/undervisning_og_arrangementer/2010/ARTISTS__CAREERS_191010.pdf">8.4 percent lower</a> than the rest of the labor market, according to 2000 Census data).</p>
<p><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="aligncenter wp-image-9081" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/untitled-presentation-3-1-1024x870.png" alt="untitled-presentation (3)" width="407" height="346" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/untitled-presentation-3-1-1024x870.png 1024w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/untitled-presentation-3-1-300x255.png 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/untitled-presentation-3-1-768x653.png 768w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/untitled-presentation-3-1.png 1200w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 407px) 100vw, 407px" /></p>
<p style="text-align: center;">Graphic by Shawn Lent for Createquity. Source: <a href="https://nces.ed.gov/ipeds/datacenter/">U.S. Department of Education IPEDS Survey</a></p>
<p>Particularly on a discipline-specific basis, the conditions leading up to the decision to pursue professional artistry may represent <a href="https://createquity.com/issue/disparities/">disparities of access</a>. If it were the case that high school graduates who aspired to artistic careers couldn’t pursue their dreams because of the risk aversion associated with low SES, that would be a major failing of a <a href="https://createquity.com/about/a-healthy-arts-ecosystem/">healthy arts ecosystem</a>.</p>
<p style="text-align: left;">Given that, it’s probably a blessing in disguise that you don’t need an arts degree to become an artist. In fact, the preponderance of upper-middle-class students in programs offering those degrees might well indicate that poorer, emerging artists are making informed decisions that are in their best interests. Everyone’s situation is different, and statistics can only tell us so much about an individual case. But if you’re worried that an expensive four-year degree is your only way to the top of the arts heap, you can take heart in the knowledge that many, many creators and performers have made it there without one.</p>
<p style="text-align: left;"><strong><em>In the <a href="https://createquity.com/2016/08/createquity-podcast-series-2-the-cost-of-being-creative/" target="_blank">latest Createquity podcast series</a>, Createquity and Fractured Atlas team members illuminate the major factors that contribute to artists (or prevent artists from) establishing successful careers. We also focus on some of the tools Fractured Atlas has developed to support artists, with the larger goal of helping create a more navigable and equitable ecosystem for professional artists. </em></strong></p>
<p style="text-align: left;"><em>Cover image: “<a class="external" href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/kcadams/sets/72157653025897185/" target="_blank">Hiram College Commencement 2015</a>,” courtesy of Kasey-Samuel Adams via Flickr Creative Commons license. </em></p>
]]></content:encoded>
			<wfw:commentRss>https://createquity.com/2016/05/the-bfas-dance-with-inequality/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
		<slash:comments>12</slash:comments>
			<dc:creator><![CDATA[Louise Geraghty]]></dc:creator>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Feldman]]></dc:creator>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Talia Gibas]]></dc:creator>
	</item>
		<item>
		<title>Who Will Be the Next Arts Revolutionary?</title>
		<link>https://createquity.com/2016/03/who-will-be-the-next-arts-revolutionary/</link>
		<comments>https://createquity.com/2016/03/who-will-be-the-next-arts-revolutionary/#comments</comments>
		<pubDate>Mon, 07 Mar 2016 16:00:03 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Shawn Lent, Katie Ingersoll, Michael Feldman and Talia Gibas]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[Features]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[501(c)(3)]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[capacity to create change]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[cultural equity]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[diversity]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Ford Foundation]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[history of the arts ecosystem]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[JFK]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[McNeil Lowry]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Nancy Hanks]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[NEA]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[nonprofit sector]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Rockefeller Foundation]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[rural arts]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Twentieth Century Fund]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://createquity.com/?p=8767</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[The story of how the nonprofit arts sector got started offers would-be changemakers some clues.]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Take a listen to <a href="http://www.giarts.org/article/please-dont-start-theater-company">Voice 1</a>:</p>
<blockquote><p>In the past fifteen years, the number of nonprofit theater companies in the United States has doubled while audiences and funding have shrunk. Neither the field nor the next generation of artists is served by this unexamined multiplication&#8230;There has been tremendous collective buy-in to what has become a fossilized model.</p>
<p style="text-align: right;">—<em>Rebecca No</em><i>vick, theater director and arts consultant</i></p>
</blockquote>
<p>Then hear out <a href="http://nonprofitwithballs.com/2014/06/the-game-of-nonprofit-and-how-it-leaves-some-communities-behind/">Voice 2</a>:</p>
<blockquote><p>We communities of color are still trying to understand the mainstream nonprofit culture, with all its unwritten rules and regulations. We are trying to be better nonprofit players. We have to, because the game is not going to change any time soon, and those communities who don’t know the rules or who don’t practice enough are left behind… We have no choice.</p>
<p style="text-align: right;">—<em>Vu</em><i> Le, executive director of Rainier Valley Corps</i></p>
</blockquote>
<p>Stop and reflect on <a href="http://www.vanderbilt.edu/curbcenter/files/Chronicle-America-Needs-a-New-System1.pdf">Voice 3</a>:</p>
<blockquote><p>I&#8217;ve always been a bit uncomfortable with our sector&#8217;s be-all-and-end-all focus on the needs of the nonprofit arts… The sector has grown bigger without getting richer.</p>
<p style="text-align: right;"><i>—Bill Ivey, former chairman of the National Endowment for the Arts</i></p>
</blockquote>
<p>See if you agree with <a href="http://theabundantartist.com/go-your-own-way-fiscal-sponsorship-and-for-profit-arts/">Voice 4</a>:</p>
<blockquote><p>Funding organizations really do roll their eyes these days, when yet another nonprofit, pops up with its hands out. Reality: no one is gonna pay your tab.</p>
<p style="text-align: right;">—<em>Misha Pento</em><i>n, opera singer, theater artist, and artistic director of Divergence Vocal Theater </i></p>
</blockquote>
<p>Opinions about the nonprofit arts model—the fundamental legal and business structure in which arts nonprofits in the United States work—are as numerous and varied as 501(c)(3)s themselves. But one thing all of these quotes take for granted is the existence of the model itself. While that system may seem “fossilized” to some, the truth is that most arts nonprofits today are younger than most of our parents. The boom of arts nonprofits has been a relatively recent phenomenon, and it came about thanks in large part to a handful of individuals who intentionally put it into motion.</p>
<div id="attachment_8783" style="width: 603px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://createquity.com/2016/03/notes-to-who-will-be-the-next-arts-revolutionary"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-8783" class="wp-image-8783" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/untitled-presentation-8-1024x870.png" alt="Infographic 1" width="593" height="504" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/untitled-presentation-8-1024x870.png 1024w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/untitled-presentation-8-300x255.png 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/untitled-presentation-8-768x653.png 768w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/untitled-presentation-8.png 1200w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 593px) 100vw, 593px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-8783" class="wp-caption-text">Graphic by Shawn Lent and Katherine Ingersoll for Createquity. See <a href="https://createquity.com/2016/03/notes-to-who-will-be-the-next-arts-revolutionary">endnotes</a> for additional detail on sourcing.</p></div>
<p>The story of the nonprofit model is <a href="https://www.independentsector.org/scope_of_the_sector">part of the broader heritage of nonprofits</a>, and follows a similar trajectory. A combination of intentional interventions and societal factors led to a massive expansion of the nonprofit sector in the United States in the middle of the 20th century, both in terms of size and portion of overall economic activity. Nonprofit expenses and assets actually <a href="http://www.urban.org/publications/901011.html">outpaced the economy</a> between 1994 and 2004 primarily thanks to the growth of hospitals, health organizations and private colleges. In 2012, there was <a href="http://www.urban.org/features/nonprofit-almanac-and-almanac-briefs">1 nonprofit for every 175 Americans</a>.</p>
<p>Despite such a boom, life inside the current arts ecosystem is not all it could be. Createquity’s mission is to identify the most important issues in the arts and what we can do about them, but a crucial barrier to executing on that premise is the sector’s limited <a href="https://createquity.com/issue/capacity/">capacity to create change</a>. While the 501(c)(3) arts model offers infrastructure that, in theory, combines artistic aspiration with public accountability, the decentralization and limited scope of government policy make large-scale, systemic change in the sector difficult to accomplish. Yet Createquity’s long-range goal is to do exactly that, or at the very least to catalyze it.</p>
<blockquote><p>One of the things that I pray for is that people with power will get good sense, and that people with good sense will get power&#8230;</p>
<p style="text-align: right;">—<i>Dixie Carter as <a href="http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0558661/">Julia Sugarbaker</a></i></p>
</blockquote>
<p>To accurately predict how change can happen in the arts ecosystem, it would help to understand how change has already taken place in our arts 501(c)(3) genealogy. Specifically, we want to know whether individuals or organizations can truly and intentionally marshal change, or if a cloudy mix of circumstances is responsible for where we are today. Has transformation in the arts sector historically been calculated and choreographed, or organic and inadvertent?</p>
<p>It turns out that a narrow time period starting in the mid-1950s and ending in the late 1970s presents clear examples of deliberate and broad action, precipitating one of the most extensive changes in the arts ecosystem: the spread and embrace of the nonprofit model as a mechanism for cultivating and promoting the arts and culture within the United States.</p>
<p>But first, some time travel is in order.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><a href="https://createquity.com/2016/03/notes-to-who-will-be-the-next-arts-revolutionary"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="aligncenter wp-image-8801" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/output_CKo3Qj.gif" alt="Time Travel GIF" width="382" height="242" /></a></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h1 style="text-align: left;"><b>THE ARTS ECOSYSTEM’S EARLY DAYS</b></h1>
<p>The modern tax code, including the arts 501(c)(3) status we know today, was <a href="https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-soi/tehistory.pdf">established in 1954</a>, but its roots stretch back much farther. Several of our nation’s first theaters and museums were built before the American Revolution, but voluntary associations in this colonial period (as well as in the freshly independent years following the war) were limited by the strong role of the church and emboldened by the lack of federal authority over them. The landmark 1819 Supreme Court decision of <a href="https://pantherfile.uwm.edu/mordecai/www/Dartmouth-longversion.pdf">Trustees of Dartmouth College vs. Woodward</a> further constrained the government’s power to intervene in private charitable organizations and set protection for incorporated endowments, including the few for arts institutions.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="aligncenter wp-image-8813" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/1.png" alt="Timeline graphic by Shawn Lent" width="636" height="353" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/1.png 810w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/1-300x167.png 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/1-768x427.png 768w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 636px) 100vw, 636px" /></p>
<p>From the <a href="http://www.metmuseum.org/about-the-museum/history-of-the-museum/main-building">Met</a> to the <a href="http://chicagotonight.wttw.com/2012/01/30/hull-house-art">Hull House</a>, arts participation in 19th century America was shaped by class division. Urban wealthy elites, their formal governing sway slipping away in a democratic society, <a href="https://books.google.com/books?hl=en&amp;lr=&amp;id=7n8dPi2ew9YC&amp;oi=fnd&amp;pg=PA32&amp;dq=%22nonprofit+organizations%22+infrastructure+history&amp;ots=1AlPoomYZM&amp;sig=sD_W1aPNVRI5eAwsU5nRASPF7N8#v=onepage&amp;q=%22nonprofit%20organizations%22%20infrastructure%20history&amp;f=false">established private organizations</a> to advance the greater good—and to preserve their class status. In the wake of civil war and the <a href="http://www.loc.gov/teachers/classroommaterials/presentationsandactivities/presentations/timeline/riseind/immgnts/">arrival of nearly 12 million immigrants</a>, Americans formed mutual aid societies and unions, but also private schools, libraries, social clubs, and a scattering of non-commercial museums and symphony orchestras.</p>
<p>Donations from wealthy individuals were the most important source of support, and policymakers in the late 1800s introduced the country’s <a href="https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-soi/tehistory.pdf">first statutory references and implementation of tax exemption</a> for charitable organizations. In 1889, a certain Mr. Andrew Carnegie published “<a href="http://historymatters.gmu.edu/d/5767">Wealth</a>,” an essay pressing other tycoons to join him in donating considerable percentages of their fortunes for the good of society, including the arts and humanities. Years later, historians would credit Carnegie with conceptualizing what is now the modern philanthropic foundation.</p>
<div id="attachment_8773" style="width: 471px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/9Te3US"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-8773" class="wp-image-8773 " src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/5830541690_24f5c928a7_b-1024x768.jpg" alt="&quot;The Immigrants,&quot; by Luis Sanguino in Battery Park" width="461" height="345" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/5830541690_24f5c928a7_b.jpg 1024w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/5830541690_24f5c928a7_b-300x225.jpg 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/5830541690_24f5c928a7_b-768x576.jpg 768w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 461px) 100vw, 461px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-8773" class="wp-caption-text">&#8220;The Immigrants,&#8221; by Luis Sanguino in Battery Park &#8211; photo by flickr user k31thw</p></div>
<p>Even so, through the rip-roaring early part of the 20th century, the dominant vehicle for performing arts enterprises, from jazz clubs to theater ensembles, was the <a href="http://www.giarts.org/article/leverage-lost">commercial sole proprietorship</a>. As the socioeconomic gap became a socioeconomic crater, philanthropic support for arts nonprofits remained limited and highly <a href="http://www.philanthropyroundtable.org/topic/excellence_in_philanthropy/the_birth_of_big_time_fundraising">localized</a>. Coming out of the Great Depression and WWII, national foundations like Carnegie’s were primarily setting their sights on educational goals.</p>
<p>All the while, <a href="https://createquity.com/2016/03/notes-to-who-will-be-the-next-arts-revolutionary#Note1">countless early arts pioneers, renegades, and boat rockers</a> had the ambition to innovate on the local level, and many eventually saw the fruits of their efforts spread to varying degrees. But it wasn’t until the middle of the 20th century that the stage was set for sweeping transformation for the arts at the national level.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h1 style="text-align: left;"><b>A MAN ON A MISSION<br />
</b></h1>
<blockquote>
<p style="text-align: left;">There are people who more than others constantly see themselves between past and future, &#8230;both in their own lives and in the history of mankind. And I’m one of those persons.</p>
</blockquote>
<p style="text-align: right;"><a href="http://www.americansforthearts.org/by-program/reports-and-data/legislation-policy/naappd/the-awkward-embrace-the-creative-artist-and-the-institution-in-america">—W. McNeil Lowry</a></p>
<p>In the early 1950s, an executive named William McPeak participated in a study group for the <a href="http://www.fordfoundation.org/about-us/history">Ford Foundation</a>, which was exploring potential new structures and priorities as it prepared to become the largest foundation in the world. McPeak was pushing Ford to include the humanities in its vision for the future. One of his confidants during that struggle was W. McNeil “Mac” Lowry, a civilian journalist with <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/1993/06/07/obituaries/w-mcneil-lowry-is-dead-patron-of-the-arts-was-80.html">the Washington bureau of Cox Newspapers</a> who had been McPeak&#8217;s colleague at the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Office_of_War_Information#Controversies_at_home">Office of Wartime Information</a>. Ford ultimately decided against funding the humanities when it expanded its scope from serving Detroit to focusing on social justice nationally and internationally, moving its office to New York City, but McPeak was hired as Ford’s Associate Director in 1953 and he <a href="http://archives.library.illinois.edu/ead/ua/2620096/2620096b.html">brought Lowry on board</a> as his assistant.</p>
<p>Two years into his tenure, Lowry was promoted to Program Director for Education and started suggesting ad hoc humanities grants under this education arm. They were small and few, and they were accepted. He also began writing policy papers and advocating internally for the creation of a large, full-fledged arts and humanities funding arm. This proposal was bold and unprecedented for any foundation at the time. With persistence and McPeak’s partnership, a mere four years after joining the foundation, Lowry was named director of its newly minted Division of Humanities and the Arts.</p>
<p>Lowry aimed to leverage Ford’s dollars and influence toward a <a href="http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/01/04/what-money-can-buy-profiles-larissa-macfarquhar">grand vision of a robust arts field </a>across the United States, but he started with a more tangible and comprehensible project: an inventory of the field conducted through interviews with artists and arts stakeholders, which would subsequently inform the decision on the part of <a href="https://www.fordfoundation.org/library/annual-reports/1956-annual-report/">Ford’s trustees </a>whether to make the program permanent.</p>
<div id="attachment_8772" style="width: 516px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/ahbzfL"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-8772" class="wp-image-8772" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/6090337836_d0921ca137_b-1-1024x768.jpg" alt="ripple effect" width="506" height="380" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/6090337836_d0921ca137_b-1.jpg 1024w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/6090337836_d0921ca137_b-1-300x225.jpg 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/6090337836_d0921ca137_b-1-768x576.jpg 768w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 506px) 100vw, 506px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-8772" class="wp-caption-text">ripple effect &#8211; photo by flickr user Judy van der Velden</p></div>
<p>Lowry knew that his audience didn’t initially take his project very seriously. But as his assistant Marcia Thompson put it, it quickly became clear that the trustees “<a href="http://www.americansforthearts.org/by-program/reports-and-data/legislation-policy/naappd/the-awkward-embrace-the-creative-artist-and-the-institution-in-america">were not only entertained but were enormously interested in the field.</a>” Lowry <a href="http://www.americansforthearts.org/by-program/reports-and-data/legislation-policy/naappd/the-awkward-embrace-the-creative-artist-and-the-institution-in-america">later said of his thinking</a>,</p>
<blockquote>
<p style="text-align: left;">It was not any secret to me what the little start of that program in 1957 might mean on a national basis&#8230; It’s just, you couldn’t divulge it because it was still dream and plan… <b>This work is… a little bit like casting a stone in a puddle, but precisely which stone and precisely which puddle and for precisely which effect [is] the real creative part of it. </b></p>
</blockquote>
<p>He and Thompson began by giving themselves the task of creating a directory with the names and contact information of every art critic and artist they could find around the country. Long before digital spreadsheets or the Internet, this was a hefty self-assignment. A former journalist with <a href="http://www.trumanlibrary.org/oralhist/lowrywm.htm">a history of telling it like it is</a>, Lowry was willing to question loyalties and cliques. For example, he worked to extend professional arts opportunities outside major metropolitan areas even though several Ford trustees with connections to prominent New York institutions pushed back. He, along with associate director <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/1991/05/03/obituaries/edward-f-d-arms-87-executive-and-teacher.html">Edward F. D’Arms</a>, <a href="http://howlround.com/what-history-can-teach-us-about-arts-philanthropy-in-the-age-of-obama">traveled the country to speak with artists and stakeholders at over 175 arts companies</a>. Lowry’s was a personal approach which gave him strong buy-in and trust from people who were actually engaged in arts work; he preferred <a href="http://www.philanthropyroundtable.org/almanac/the_arts_and_culture/1953_cultural_kingmaker_at_the_ford_foundation">direct correspondence</a> with prospective grantees, including the likes of James Baldwin and Tom Stoppard. Lowry synthesized this mountain of data with more formal knowledge from economics and policy to begin to design the functions of Ford’s arts program.</p>
<div id="attachment_8771" style="width: 566px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/A6xyn3"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-8771" class="wp-image-8771" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/22378869932_209033278b_b-1024x655.jpg" alt="Columbus, Ohio's State Capitol from the Air (1957)" width="556" height="356" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/22378869932_209033278b_b.jpg 1024w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/22378869932_209033278b_b-300x192.jpg 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/22378869932_209033278b_b-768x491.jpg 768w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 556px) 100vw, 556px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-8771" class="wp-caption-text">Columbus, Ohio&#8217;s State Capitol from the Air (1957) &#8211; photo by flickr user Sent from the Past</p></div>
<p>Choosing to start with theater as his first arts discipline, Lowry used his new directory to send out a wide call for proposals, looking for groups (many of which were either sole proprietorships or amateur projects at the time) that seemed ready for the next step in professionalization. The focus was on smaller organizations outside the big cities because he did not want to see “<a href="http://www.americansforthearts.org/by-program/reports-and-data/legislation-policy/naappd/the-awkward-embrace-the-creative-artist-and-the-institution-in-america">money that could go to artists and artistic directors or to their outlets put in bricks and mortar.</a>” With an <a href="http://www.americantheatre.org/2015/06/16/going-national-how-americas-regional-theatre-movement-changed-the-game/">investment of $9 million</a> in 1961, the Ford Foundation had gathered steam for what would become the <a href="http://www.americantheatre.org/2015/06/16/going-national-how-americas-regional-theatre-movement-changed-the-game/">regional theater movement</a>. After seven years of commercial operation, <a href="https://www.tcg.org/publications/at/2001/zelda.cfm">Zelda Fichandler</a> transformed DC’s Arena Stage into one of the country’s first nonprofit theaters, <a href="http://blog.americansforthearts.org/2011/05/16/l3c-cha-cha-cha">primarily to receive a grant from the Ford Foundation</a>.</p>
<p>One of Lowry’s primary aims was to increase the amount of professional performing arts activity in the country, but he wanted to be inclusive whenever possible. He had intended to fund a black theater when he launched the program in 1957 but was unable to locate a promising black artistic director able to get a new theater up and running. A couple years after Martin Luther King Jr. inspired the country with his dream of integration, a playwright named Douglas Turner Ward wrote an editorial in the New York Times about the need for a black theater, supporting disenfranchised artists, managers, writers, and designers. Lowry read the article and contacted Ward immediately. Shortly after, with a Ford grant of $434,000 ($3.3 million in 2016 dollars), Ward, producer/actor Robert Hooks and theater manager Gerald Krone would establish the <a href="http://necinc.org/history/">Negro Ensemble Theatre Company</a> in 1965.</p>
<p>Lowry got artists out of their comfort zones and towards professionalization, and was well aware of the consequences of him doing so. <a href="http://www.americansforthearts.org/by-program/reports-and-data/legislation-policy/naappd/the-awkward-embrace-the-creative-artist-and-the-institution-in-america">As he describes it</a>,</p>
<blockquote><p>[artistic producers] had to think about ‘where does this move us to the next phase?’&#8230;They took on costly activities that they had ignored before…. So they were stretched. And some of them were even shrewd enough to say in advance of a grant, ‘You’re going to stretch me, aren’t you?’ I’d say, ‘Yes, I’m sorry, that’s an inevitable consequence of this.’”</p></blockquote>
<p>Under his direction, arts grants now required matching dollars for the first time and arts grantees were pushed to improve their marketing practices. For example, he directly supported <a href="http://www.bruceduffie.com/dannynewman.html">Danny Newman</a>, the press agent at Chicago Lyric Opera, to evangelize the subscription model to performing arts organizations across the country.</p>
<p>Lowry’s legacy also stretched entire segments of the performing arts. During his tenure, Ford <a href="http://howlround.com/what-history-can-teach-us-about-arts-philanthropy-in-the-age-of-obama#sthash.HGqXojMB.dpu">invested $19.5 million to help build 17 resident professional theaters between 1962 and 1976,</a> and was the first American foundation to fund dance on a large scale (<a href="http://www.americansforthearts.org/by-program/reports-and-data/legislation-policy/naappd/the-awkward-embrace-the-creative-artist-and-the-institution-in-america">$22.5 million from 1957-1973</a>). Ford&#8217;s largest arts investment over this time was <a href="http://www.americansforthearts.org/by-program/reports-and-data/legislation-policy/naappd/the-awkward-embrace-the-creative-artist-and-the-institution-in-america">the Symphony Orchestra Program ($80.2 million)</a>. Lowry retired from his position as Vice President at Ford in 1974, and passed away in 1993.</p>
<p>Mac Lowry could easily be labeled one of the nonprofit arts sector’s most significant figures of all time. No exaggeration. Lincoln Kirstein, co-founder of the New York City Ballet, <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/1993/06/07/obituaries/w-mcneil-lowry-is-dead-patron-of-the-arts-was-80.html">described Lowry</a> as “the single most influential patron of the performing arts that the American democratic system has produced.” By changing the financial incentives for artists, he directly helped to create an entire field of professional, nonprofit performing arts institutions. Thanks to Lowry, Ford became not only the first foundation to fund arts institutions on a large scale (making <a href="http://www.americansforthearts.org/by-program/reports-and-data/legislation-policy/naappd/the-awkward-embrace-the-creative-artist-and-the-institution-in-america">$249.8 million worth of arts grants 1957-1973</a>,<a href="http://www.americansforthearts.org/by-program/reports-and-data/legislation-policy/naappd/the-awkward-embrace-the-creative-artist-and-the-institution-in-america"> or nearly $2 billion in today’s dollars</a>), but also the largest nongovernmental funder of the nonprofit performing arts.</p>
<p>In this position, the Ford Foundation was able to exert considerable influence on the sector. Bill Ivey notes that “<a href="http://www.vanderbilt.edu/curbcenter/files/Chronicle-America-Needs-a-New-System1.pdf">the &#8216;Ford model&#8217; remains the gold standard shaping intervention in America&#8217;s arts system.</a>” Decades later, Ford is 5th on a list of the <a href="http://www.giarts.org/sites/default/files/ArtsFundingStudy1999.pdf">top 25 arts funders</a>, which underscores how the number of foundations interested in the arts has grown over time, and the strength of Lowry’s legacy in philanthropy.</p>
<p>At the Ford Foundation, Lowry had been given wide latitude to try new things, with a significant amount of money. His success had always been boosted by internal support from McPeak, but in 1966 Ford welcomed one of its more liberal presidents, McGeorge Bundy, who came to Ford from the Johnson administration and his “Great Society” programs. Under Bundy’s leadership, Ford was an instigator of public-private philanthropy and Lowry was able to connect to the subsidy argument of federal support for the arts. <a href="https://books.google.com/books/about/The_Arts_and_Public_Policy_in_the_United.html?id=jVNQAAAAMAAJ">Lowry later reflected that</a> “a pervasive effect of the Ford program was the enlightenment that began to spread not only about the importance of nonprofit artistic enterprises, but more precisely their justification for subsidy.”</p>
<p>Lowry and his colleagues were able to ride a wave of public support and concern while acknowledging and working with, not against, broader political agendas. To Createquity, this insight seems critical to understanding why monumental change could take place when it did, and it raises the question of how such transformation could be possible in our current polarized political climate.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="aligncenter wp-image-8831 " src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/1-1.png" alt="1" width="605" height="336" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/1-1.png 810w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/1-1-300x167.png 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/1-1-768x427.png 768w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 605px) 100vw, 605px" /></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h1 style="text-align: left;"><b>THREE ARTS PRESIDENTS AND A NANCY</b></h1>
<p>With standoffs with Vladimir Putin and strikes at orchestras, theaters and beyond dominating modern newsfeeds, it is difficult to imagine a contemporary POTUS declaring the arts as a diplomatic weapon against Russia or sending the Secretary of Labor to personally mediate a dispute between a major arts institution and its workers. Yet in the late 1950s and early 1960s, that is exactly what happened.</p>
<p>As Lowry’s influence at Ford evolved, so did the operative role of the federal government in the arts. President Eisenhower, a Republican, advocated in his 1955 State of the Union address for the establishment of a Federal Advisory Commission on the Arts. This was cultural <a href="http://www.vqronline.org/essay/cultural-cold-war-history">cold war</a>: as <a href="https://www.tcg.org/publications/at/2001/zelda.cfm">one artistic director put it</a>, “Eisenhower spoke of a lack of achievement in the cultural sphere: Who did we have to export in terms of ballet, opera and theatre companies? How could we compete with Russia, which had such a rich cultural spectrum of performing arts?”</p>
<div id="attachment_8770" style="width: 510px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/aw1e2h"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-8770" class="wp-image-8770" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/6246749598_b628141af7_b-1-1024x692.jpg" alt="Bolshoi Ballet Theatre in Moscow" width="500" height="338" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/6246749598_b628141af7_b-1.jpg 1024w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/6246749598_b628141af7_b-1-300x203.jpg 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/6246749598_b628141af7_b-1-768x519.jpg 768w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 500px) 100vw, 500px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-8770" class="wp-caption-text">Bolshoi Ballet Theatre in Moscow &#8211; photo by flickr user appaIoosa</p></div>
<p>Although Eisenhower was <a href="https://books.google.com/books?id=f0v5ZwQWEL8C&amp;lpg=PA280&amp;pg=PA21#v=onepage&amp;q&amp;f=false">all talk and little action on the arts</a> and no formal advisory body was created during his two terms, he did have one major accomplishment: the passing of the National Cultural Center Act of Congress in 1958, which would set the stage for the founding of a certain, prominent national performing arts center on the Potomac River thirteen years later.</p>
<p>Two years later, John F. Kennedy won the election with a party platform that included <a href="http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa137.html">a brief mention</a> of &#8220;a federal advisory agency to assist in the evaluation, development, and expansion of cultural resources.” Although he didn’t have a cultural agenda, the Kennedy Administration would be the one to finally elevate cultural policy to a national priority.</p>
<p>During his first year as President, Kennedy had the White House taking direct action in the arts. When the American Federation of Musicians Local 802 led a strike against The Metropolitan Opera during his first year in office, Kennedy sent Secretary of Labor Arthur Goldberg to arbitrate the salary <a href="http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa137.htm">dispute</a> that had halted the current production season. While serving as the mediator in his office, Goldberg suggested that government funds be used to help settle the Met’s $840,000 debt (that would be more than $6.6 million federal dollars today used to bail out a private arts institution); it’s a safe bet today’s Congress would not get behind that.</p>
<p>Possibly influenced by <a href="http://www.upenn.edu/pnc/ptkoch.html">Jacqueline Kennedy’s love for the arts</a>, President Kennedy expanded his public support, <a href="https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/nea-history-1965-2008.pdf">saying</a>, “The life of the arts, far from being an interruption, a distraction, in the life of a nation, is very close to the center of a nation’s purpose . . . and is a test of the quality of a nation’s civilization.” In contrast to Eisenhower’s cold war logic, Kennedy’s policy vision would position arts and culture as sources of national hope and solidarity, continuing to push toward both a national center and a federal agency for arts and culture.</p>
<p>President Kennedy was active in the arts right up until his shocking murder in Dallas. In 1963 alone, he emphasized the importance of <a href="http://www.jfklibrary.org/Research/Research-Aids/JFK-Speeches/Amherst-College_19631026.aspx">national recognition of the arts</a> in a speech at the dedication of the Robert Frost Library at Amherst College; established the <a href="http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/index.php?pid=9275&amp;st=advisory+council+on+the+arts&amp;st1=">Advisory Council on the Arts</a> (not appointed until after his death); and commissioned a <a href="http://catalog.hathitrust.org/Record/007904621">report</a> by August Heckscher, director of the Twentieth Century Fund and his special consultant for the arts, on the <a href="http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa137.html">relationship between the arts and the Federal government</a>.</p>
<p>Together, these resources laid the foundation for the ultimate achievement in linking federal government to arts and culture, the signing of the <a href="https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/NEAChronWeb.pdf">National Endowment for the Arts</a> and National Endowment for the Humanities into law in 1965 by President Lyndon Baines Johnson. Johnson chose Roger Lacey Stevens, a Broadway <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/1998/02/04/arts/roger-l-stevens-real-estate-magnate-producer-and-fund-raiser-is-dead-at-87.html">producer</a> who had led the fundraising efforts for the National Cultural Center (later renamed <a href="http://www.kennedy-center.org/pages/about/history">The John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts</a>), as the NEA’s first Chairman and Special Assistant on the Arts.</p>
<div id="attachment_8774" style="width: 506px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/BRgVwr"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-8774" class="wp-image-8774 " src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/23530101921_cd2a9a339f_k-1024x683.jpg" alt="NEH Chairman William Adams tours the Lyndon B. Johnson Presidential Library exhibits" width="496" height="331" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/23530101921_cd2a9a339f_k-1024x683.jpg 1024w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/23530101921_cd2a9a339f_k-300x200.jpg 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/23530101921_cd2a9a339f_k-768x512.jpg 768w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/23530101921_cd2a9a339f_k.jpg 2048w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 496px) 100vw, 496px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-8774" class="wp-caption-text">NEH Chairman William Adams tours the Lyndon B. Johnson Presidential Library exhibits &#8211; photo by the LBJ Foundation on flickr</p></div>
<p>Following Stevens’s brief inaugural tenure as NEA Chairman, <a href="https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/nea-history-1965-2008.pdf">Nancy Hanks</a> (not the mother of the 16th President of the United States, for whom she is descended and named), was selected to head the search for his successor. After <a href="http://biography.yourdictionary.com/nancy-hanks">several prominent figures had turned the position down</a>, Hanks herself was appointed by President Nixon in 1969; according to Stevens, &#8220;<a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/lifestyle/1983/01/10/nancy-hanks-gentle-persuasion/b6b3b39e-7505-404b-9732-75e29a2baee5/">they were looking for some women for jobs.</a>&#8221; She was a Southern Republican and a Duke University graduate who began her career as a <a href="http://biography.yourdictionary.com/nancy-hanks">DC receptionist</a> and later gained White House experience as assistant to Nelson A. Rockefeller and his arts programs. Afterward, while on staff at The Rockefeller Brothers Fund, Hanks published the influential report, <i>The Performing Arts: Problems &amp; Prospects</i> (1965). By the end of the 1960s, she had both been named <a href="https://books.google.com/books?id=EImTCwAAQBAJ&amp;lpg=PT128&amp;ots=4V0fnTppzb&amp;dq=nancy%20hanks%20nea&amp;pg=PT127#v=onepage&amp;q=nancy%20hanks%20nea&amp;f=false">president of the Associated Council on the Arts (ACA)</a> and diagnosed with cancer. She chose to remain unmarried and without children; she would later be deemed the <a href="http://biography.yourdictionary.com/nancy-hanks">mother of a million artists</a>.</p>
<p>Amidst the burgeoning feminist movement, Hanks took the reins of a then-nascent NEA with grander aims for the agency. In her first six weeks at the helm of the NEA, <a href="http://biography.yourdictionary.com/nancy-hanks#7JDbVG307utbjwsS.99">she personally spoke to 200 Congressmen to advocate for her proposal to double the budget</a> and to secure future appropriations for the nation’s bicentennial, which was more than six years ahead. Hanks was a sagacious power; her office became a lobbying machine.</p>
<p><a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/lifestyle/1983/01/10/nancy-hanks-gentle-persuasion/b6b3b39e-7505-404b-9732-75e29a2baee5/"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="aligncenter wp-image-8793" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/output_zBQZaR-1.gif" alt="output_zBQZaR" width="444" height="372" /></a></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p>She battled her cancer quietly while strongarming Congress, protecting NEA political territory, and preempting controversies for the agency. In 1970, when the NEA budget faced the ax, Hanks and her assistant <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/1983/01/08/obituaries/nancy-hanks-dead-at-55-headed-national-arts-group.html">individually cornered over 100 Congressmen</a> and succeeded in swaying their votes. Julia Butler Hansen, a Democrat from Washington State and chairwoman of the House appropriations subcommittee during that term, said she needed to see <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/lifestyle/1983/01/10/nancy-hanks-gentle-persuasion/b6b3b39e-7505-404b-9732-75e29a2baee5/">letters from constituents</a> to be convinced, so Hanks somehow got a form letter onto every theater seat in the country and, within a few weeks, had thousands of them into Hansen&#8217;s mailbox. When artists won prestigious prizes, Hanks would send out letters to the Representatives of their home states, reminding them that &#8220;<a href="http://www.nytimes.com/1983/01/08/obituaries/nancy-hanks-dead-at-55-headed-national-arts-group.html">good artists do not just happen.</a>&#8221;</p>
<p>Hanks put a large emphasis on grants to institutions, which <a href="https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=1144&amp;dat=19770922&amp;id=a1kdAAAAIBAJ&amp;sjid=6FcEAAAAIBAJ&amp;pg=6889,2878716&amp;hl=en">helped to make arts funding a bipartisan issue</a> since many wealthy board members of symphonies and museums were Republicans like her. The concept of public subsidy for the arts was sold as a cure for the “cost disease” endemic to nonprofit arts organizations. Revenue and private donations alone could not support the sector, she believed; the income gap must be filled.</p>
<p>With an <i>art-for-all-Americans </i>ethos, Hanks supported a plentitude of smaller nonprofit arts organizations in newly funded areas such as crafts. Additionally, Hanks played an instrumental role in establishing the Arts Council of Americas to unite the <a href="http://www.americansforthearts.org/by-program/reports-and-data/legislation-policy/naappd/arts-america-1780%E2%80%932015">more than 50 community arts councils already in existence</a> and in expanding the National Assembly of State Arts Agencies in order to have a well-funded state council in every state and territory in the U.S. Much of the NEA’s funding was designated to run through these state councils.</p>
<p>Later in her tenure Hanks authorized the NEA Challenge Grants, which <a href="http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/09548963.2013.817645">demanded matching contributions</a> to leverage investment from the private sector. This was <a href="http://www.giarts.org/article/leverage-lost">a strategy similar to those of the Ford Foundation in the 1960s and the Johnson Administration&#8217;s War on Poverty.</a></p>
<p>Before Hanks, the NEA was more of a figurehead organization with a modest budget; by 1976, it was the <a href="https://books.google.com/books/about/Philanthropy_and_the_Nonprofit_Sector_in.html?id=195wkm6SoOsC&amp;source=kp_read&amp;printsec=frontcover&amp;source=kp_read_button#v=onepage&amp;q&amp;f=false">largest institutional funder of the arts in the country</a>. In brief, she was the <a href="https://books.google.com/books?id=EImTCwAAQBAJ&amp;lpg=PT128&amp;ots=4V0fnTppzb&amp;dq=nancy%20hanks%20nea&amp;pg=PT127#v=onepage&amp;q=nancy%20hanks%20nea&amp;f=false">savviest operator in the NEA’s history</a>. She served two terms as the NEA chair until her resignation in 1977, and she died of her cancer six years later at age 55. A mere three weeks after her passing, President Reagan (whose economic policies were threatening the existence of the NEA and NEH at the time) signed a law renaming NEA and NEH’s erstwhile home, the Old Post Office, in Washington, D.C. the Nancy Hanks Center.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<div id="attachment_8769" style="width: 495px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/o1nyNV"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-8769" class="wp-image-8769" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/14444056617_99d5fc5865_o.jpg" alt="Washington State Library, Go to Theatre Week, 1922" width="485" height="273" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/14444056617_99d5fc5865_o.jpg 910w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/14444056617_99d5fc5865_o-300x169.jpg 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/14444056617_99d5fc5865_o-768x432.jpg 768w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 485px) 100vw, 485px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-8769" class="wp-caption-text">Go to Theatre Week, 1922 – photo by Washington State Library</p></div>
<h1 style="text-align: left;"><b>HOW LOWRY AND HANKS CHANGED THE ARTS NONPROFIT SECTOR FOREVER</b></h1>
<p>Neither Lowry nor Hanks saw themselves as artists (Hanks said her only art form was “<a href="https://books.google.com/books?id=EImTCwAAQBAJ&amp;lpg=PT128&amp;ots=4V0fnTppzb&amp;dq=nancy%20hanks%20nea&amp;pg=PT128#v=onepage&amp;q=nancy%20hanks%20nea&amp;f=false">needlepoint typewriter covers</a>”; others said that it clearly <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/1983/01/08/obituaries/nancy-hanks-dead-at-55-headed-national-arts-group.html">persuasion</a>), yet both were passionate in building towards a new arts vision for America, supporting and connecting artists nationwide. They were willing to defy the expectations and design of their jobs in order to create financial and structural support for artists. Both traveled the country for the cause; Lowry to discover promising artistic directors, and Hanks to advocate on their behalf.</p>
<p>Their combined legacy was to establish the current shape of the nonprofit arts sector and its mechanisms of funding. Importantly, both the Ford Foundation and the federal government brought vast new resources to the arts funding table, and directed those resources almost exclusively to nonprofit arts organizations. In doing so, not only did Lowry and Hanks catalyze the arts 501(c)(3) boom, they created the common practice of matching grants, the growth and coordination of local arts agencies, the use of grant panels, the rise of grantwriter-as-paid-employee in arts institution, and more. The influence of each can be seen in the geographic spread of infrastructure to support the arts across the country &#8212; regional theaters, dance companies, and symphony orchestras in Lowry’s case, and arts councils in Hanks’s.</p>
<p>They engineered the initial professionalization of the field. <a href="http://www.giarts.org/article/neolithic-prehistory-classical-era">Publications and conferences</a>, like those of the <a href="http://www.tcg.org/about/index.cfm">Theatre Communications Group</a> which Lowry first convened, declared and disseminated best practices. The effect of these deliberate acts was characteristic of the organizational ecology concept of “<a href="http://jom.sagepub.com/content/early/2014/03/24/0149206314527129">legitimation</a>”: as a particular type of organization becomes more accepted, it is established more and more frequently. By the mid-1970s, the nonprofit was set as the expected and dominant legal structure for new arts organizations.</p>
<p>We approached this research wanting to learn <i>how </i>change happens; we didn&#8217;t intend to dwell on whether the change has been good or bad. That said, there are several aspects of the arts ecosystem in America today that seem to have been shaped by from the transformation fostered by Lowry, Hanks, Kennedy, and others in the middle of the 20th century.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h3><b><b>There is more, more, more</b></b></h3>
<p>The timing of the boom differed by discipline, but all disciplines saw sustained growth when they began to embrace the nonprofit structure. Overall, despite <a href="http://foundationcenter.org/gainknowledge/research/pdf/artsfunding_2014.pdf">government funding cuts</a>, <a href="http://www.upenn.edu/pnc/ptkoch.html">Reaganomics and the culture wars</a>, the <a href="http://foundationcenter.org/gainknowledge/research/pdf/artsfunding2009.pdf">leveling of private funding</a>, and periodic <a href="http://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/alfresco/publication-pdfs/2000497-The-Nonprofit-Sector-in-Brief-2015-Public-Charities-Giving-and-Volunteering.pdf">recessions</a> since the 1980-90s, the number of arts nonprofit organizations has shown continued, though slowing, growth.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><a href="https://createquity.com/2016/03/notes-to-who-will-be-the-next-arts-revolutionary"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="aligncenter wp-image-8784" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/untitled-presentation-9-1024x870.png" alt="untitled-presentation (9)" width="589" height="501" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/untitled-presentation-9-1024x870.png 1024w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/untitled-presentation-9-300x255.png 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/untitled-presentation-9-768x653.png 768w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/untitled-presentation-9.png 1200w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 589px) 100vw, 589px" /></a></p>
<p>What does that growth tell us about the number of people being served by these organizations, or about the amount of art available in general? We know that as the nonprofit arts sector grows it employs more individuals; however, it is unclear whether more artists are getting paid to make art, or if there are more opportunities for artists to work as administrators, or whether more money is going to hire arts managers and educators.</p>
<p>Did the increase in the number of arts organizations contribute to higher levels of arts attendance? Several reports show increased activity in certain disciplines during the 1960-1980s, but it is unclear whether the number of arts products/activities actually increased, or if it was just that more arts experiences were made professional or formal in ways that allowed them to be counted.</p>
<p>What we do know is that as the growth of the sector appears to have yielded more opportunities and inclination for people to experience the arts. For example, there have been rising <a href="https://createquity.com/2016/03/notes-to-who-will-be-the-next-arts-revolutionary#Note2">rates of spending on arts experiences in relation to total leisure spending</a>, which can be attributed to the fact that increased institutional grant support opened up new markets.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h3><strong>Opportunities for (nonprofit) arts participation are available across the country<i> </i></strong></h3>
<p>Before Lowry and Hanks, almost all professional performing arts companies were in New York City and other metropolitan hubs on the East Coast, but the geographic spread of institutional funding starting in the 1960s has supplied arts, especially performing arts, outside of major metropolises into towns where the arts are not as commercially viable. During Hanks’s tenure, NEA grants found their way into all 50 states and six U.S. territories. Analysis by the NEA performed in both <a href="https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/23.pdf">1982 </a>and <a href="https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/63.pdf">1992</a> on the division between nonprofit and commercial performing arts companies showed that nonprofit organizations represented higher percentages of the sector <a href="https://createquity.com/2016/03/notes-to-who-will-be-the-next-arts-revolutionary#Note3">in areas that were not centers for commercial performance</a>.</p>
<h3></h3>
<h3><b style="line-height: 1.5;">American art is now much more than Eurocentric symphonies, museums and theaters</b></h3>
<p>The notion that we should remove barriers to access of the arts is now widely accepted and seems to be a legacy of Hanks’s ethos. During the 1970s-1990s, the boomers worked to <a href="http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/life/lifestyle/2011-01-01-baby-boomer-art_N.htm" target="_blank">democratize the arts</a>: careers, patronage and participation. The sector’s expansion started in the professional performing arts but then grew to support a broader range of genres and disciplines, and it’s likely that this has made a stronger mix of cultural products available to society today. Although Lowry’s early efforts were focused on professional theater, music, and dance, once the funding infrastructure was in place and the category of nonprofit arts was established, the momentum provided by the new structures and incentives fostered demands to support other artistic disciplines, and, later, the inclusion of a broader range of artistic endeavors.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<div id="attachment_8788" style="width: 544px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/e7hj28"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-8788" class="wp-image-8788" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/8603719369_e456513345_h-1024x587.jpg" alt="&quot;Heard&quot; by Nick Cave, Grand Central Terminal, March 2013" width="534" height="306" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/8603719369_e456513345_h-1024x587.jpg 1024w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/8603719369_e456513345_h-300x172.jpg 300w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/8603719369_e456513345_h-768x440.jpg 768w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/8603719369_e456513345_h.jpg 1600w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 534px) 100vw, 534px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-8788" class="wp-caption-text">&#8220;Heard&#8221; by Nick Cave, Grand Central Terminal, March 2013 &#8211; photo by flickr user j-No</p></div>
<h3><strong>The U.S. arts ecosystem is still striving for equity</strong></h3>
<p>Although more resources are available to support cultural activity since before the nonprofit arts sector boom, the nonprofit system <a href="https://createquity.com/2016/03/notes-to-who-will-be-the-next-arts-revolutionary#Note4">seems to have benefited European cultural traditions more than others, and white artists more than artists of color</a>. It has legitimately been observed that arts genres that have been accepted as high culture for longer periods <a href="https://www.princeton.edu/culturalpolicy/workpap/WP30-DiMaggio.pdf">have adopted the nonprofit form in greater numbers</a>, whereas cultural forms that have more recently come to be seen as important <a href="https://www.princeton.edu/culturalpolicy/workpap/WP30-DiMaggio.pdf">have been more likely to be commercial</a>. In 1979, <a href="https://books.google.com/books?id=ZBxMGhCQc-sC&amp;pg=PA29&amp;lpg=PA29&amp;dq=nash+minority+report+nea&amp;source=bl&amp;ots=iR-aZ5wP0I&amp;sig=KBuQLYcvJ8DzY47nkAPVb_14XN4&amp;hl=en&amp;sa=X&amp;ved=0ahUKEwjJw4CDtfPKAhWIOz4KHYl8D8gQ6AEIHDAA#v=onepage&amp;q=nash%20minority%20report%20nea&amp;f=false">only 4% of NEA grant funds were going to black arts organizations</a>, almost exclusively through its Expansion Arts initiative. In 1994, Elizabeth Broun, director of the Smithsonian&#8217;s National Museum of American Art, was <a href="http://articles.baltimoresun.com/1994-12-18/features/1994352174_1_art-collections-museum-of-american-african-american">appalled to realize that</a> &#8220;for 135 years after the founding of the federal art collections in 1829, no work by a black American was represented in the nation&#8217;s holdings.&#8221;</p>
<p>It seems that movement toward true equity in the nonprofit arts sector has been weak, slow, incomplete, or put in the hands of large institutions as part a community engagement <a href="http://nonprofitwithballs.com/2015/01/are-you-or-your-org-guilty-of-trickle-down-community-engagement/">trickle-down</a> scenario. Issues of equity in funding, leadership and audiences by race, gender, disability, etc. have manifested differently in different disciplines, but important questions linger on whether the growth of the nonprofit sector has brought with it a growth of inequality.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h1 style="text-align: left;"><b>WHERE WE GO FROM HERE</b></h1>
<p>The story of Lowry and Hanks is the story of the establishment. They were two individuals who, welcomed into institutions of wealth, power, and (white privilege), adroitly navigated those spaces in a mission to do good across the arts sector. Yet as more and more arts nonprofits sprung up over generations, the metrics they established spread like a gospel of the arts, not recognizing the full array of cultural expression people were already employing. It seems safe to assume that white cultural traditions were more robustly promoted and supported by Lowry, Hanks and their allies, <a href="https://createquity.com/2016/03/notes-to-who-will-be-the-next-arts-revolutionary/#Note5">which is why it is important to note other schismatics</a> who were integral to further developing and supporting the arts, to problematizing the relationship between nonprofit and commercial artmaking, to diversifying access and opportunity in the field, to utilizing technology, and to increasing popularity and new audiences for the arts. Influencers and moments of change like these will be explored in upcoming Createquity features.</p>
<p>Many of the sector’s successes, as well as its intractable issues, stem from the dominance of the nonprofit arts model which was driven by those formative actions in the 1950s-1960s. Lowry and his peers deliberately sought to create a healthier arts ecosystem by strengthening and professionalizing arts institutions. Yet the question is worth asking whether most institutions, thus professionalized, tend to prioritize their own preservation. <a href="https://createquity.com/about/a-healthy-arts-ecosystem/">Createquity’s definition of a healthy arts ecosystem</a> asserts that “To the extent that any element within the infrastructure is unwilling or unable to put the goal of improving people’s lives in concrete and meaningful ways first, it’s acting as a drag on the system’s capacity to change for the better. We see this problem manifesting in a number of ways, including the reluctance of cultural institutions to prioritize the interests of the ecosystem as a whole ahead of their own prosperity&#8230;” Will future changemakers be the ones who, like Lowry, are able to prioritize the entire arts ecosystem over their own institutions?</p>
<p><i>This is just the first of many articles on the capacity to create change in the arts ecosystem</i><i>. We invite you to get involved in this journey by joining us for a </i><b><i>#CreatequityAsks Twitter chat </i></b><i>on how change happens on <strong>March 17th</strong> from 7:30-8:30pm Eastern.</i></p>
<p><strong>Add to Calendar: <a href="https://addevent.com/?pV88771+outlook">Outlook</a> &#8211; <a href="https://addevent.com/?pV88771+google">Google</a> &#8211; <a href="https://addevent.com/?pV88771+yahoo">Yahoo</a> &#8211; <a href="https://addevent.com/?pV88771+outlookcom">Outlook.com</a> &#8211; <a href="https://addevent.com/?pV88771+appleical">Apple Calendar</a></strong></p>
]]></content:encoded>
			<wfw:commentRss>https://createquity.com/2016/03/who-will-be-the-next-arts-revolutionary/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
		<slash:comments>1</slash:comments>
			<dc:creator><![CDATA[Katie Ingersoll]]></dc:creator>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Feldman]]></dc:creator>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Talia Gibas]]></dc:creator>
	</item>
		<item>
		<title>Notes to &#8220;Who Will Be the Next Arts Revolutionary?&#8221;</title>
		<link>https://createquity.com/2016/03/notes-to-who-will-be-the-next-arts-revolutionary/</link>
		<comments>https://createquity.com/2016/03/notes-to-who-will-be-the-next-arts-revolutionary/#respond</comments>
		<pubDate>Mon, 07 Mar 2016 15:59:54 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Shawn Lent, Katie Ingersoll, Michael Feldman and Talia Gibas]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[Insider]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[capacity to create change]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Ford Foundation]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[history of the arts ecosystem]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[McNeil Lowry]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Nancy Hanks]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[NEA]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[nonprofit sector]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://createquity.com/?p=8779</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[The following endnotes accompany our feature article, “Who Will Be the Next Arts Revolutionary?” published on March 7, 2016: &#160; Graphic: The Boom in U.S. Nonprofits / The U.S. Arts Nonprofit Growth Spurt Reliable longitudinal data on the size of the nonprofit arts sector is difficult to come by for this period. In his 1984<a href="https://createquity.com/2016/03/notes-to-who-will-be-the-next-arts-revolutionary/" class="read-more">Read&#160;More</a>]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The following endnotes accompany our feature article, <a href="https://createquity.com/2016/03/who-will-be-the-next-arts-revolutionary/" target="_blank">“Who Will Be the Next Arts Revolutionary?”</a> published on March 7, 2016:</strong></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p><b>Graphic: The Boom in U.S. Nonprofits / The U.S. Arts Nonprofit Growth Spurt<br />
</b></p>
<p>Reliable longitudinal data on the size of the nonprofit arts sector is difficult to come by for this period. In his 1984 essay, “The Nonprofit Instrument and the Influence of the Marketplace,” Paul DiMaggio turns to founding dates of nonprofits arts organizations to demonstrate this early boom in the sector. He points out that of the 165 theatres in TGC’s Theatre Profiles IV, 87 percent were founded after 1960. He cites data in an article by Leila Sussman which examines the dance companies listed in a 1979 issue of Dance Annual and finds that 89 percent had been founded in the preceding 10 years. DiMaggio also cites a survey of New York State arts organizations, undertaken by the National Research Center for the Arts in 1975, wherein 54 percent of theatres, 58 percent of musical groups, 91 percent of dance companies, 90 percent of visual arts organizations, and 84 percent of local arts agencies had been founded in the 1960s and 70s (this data is not included in our graphic above). He also cites statistics from “national sample of art museums” that says that more than a third of them did not exists before 1960. Our data on operas and folk arts organizations is taken from other sources. In a 1993 book, James Heilbrun provides statistics on organizations in a number of disciplines. He cites data about “All Opera” companies from Central Opera Service, with 648 operas listed in 1970, and 1285 listed in 1990. Information about folk arts organizations comes from an <a href="https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/Changing-Faces-of-Tradition.pdf">NEA report published in 1996</a> about nonprofit folk arts orgs. Of 23 organizations included in the report, 19 had been founded since the 1960s.<br />
<a name="Note1"></a><br />
1. Throughout the early periods of the American arts ecosystem, numerous individuals and groups had great influence, including:</p>
<ul>
<li><a href="http://www.sil.si.edu/Exhibitions/Smithson-to-Smithsonian/1846act.htm">James Smithson</a> and his $500,000 bequest to the United States of America to found the Smithsonian Institution.</li>
<li><a href="http://www.metmuseum.org/about-the-museum/history-of-the-museum/main-building">John Jay</a>, a lawyer who rallied elites to found the Metropolitan Museum of Art, which would grow to have the <a href="http://www.statista.com/statistics/258355/cultural-institutions-in-the-us-ranked-by-size-of-endowments/">largest endowment </a>of any American cultural institution.</li>
<li>The <a href="https://tshaonline.org/handbook/online/articles/vzmvj">sociedades mutualistas</a> formed by Mexican Americans starting in the 1870s, in which traditional arts were prominent activities much like the mutual aid societies established by African, Asian, and European Americans.</li>
<li><a href="http://chicagotonight.wttw.com/2012/01/30/hull-house-art">Jane Addams</a>, the first American woman and second woman ever to win the Nobel Peace Prize, who launched a social settlement in Chicago where the <a href="http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/addams-jane/">arts were infused into the pursuit of social reform and wellbeing</a>.</li>
<li><a href="http://www.actorsequity.org/aboutequity/timeline/timeline_firstyears.html">Actors Equity Association (AEA)</a><i>,</i><a href="http://www.actorsequity.org/aboutequity/timeline/timeline_firstyears.html"><i> a</i></a> social club turned labor union, founded <i>“&#8230;not [as] a revolutionary body with anarchistic tendencies. / rather, a clearing house for a freer exchange of thought between artist and manager&#8230;” (Actors Equity Magazine 1915). </i></li>
<li><a href="http://www.biography.com/people/alain-leroy-locke-37962">Alain LeRoy Locke</a>, the first African American Rhodes Scholar, who by bringing together artists with publicity and patronage such as that of businessman <a href="https://vimeo.com/24479737">Julius Rosenwald</a>, is part of a cohort to spearhead the <a href="http://15minutehistory.org/2014/04/16/episode-50-white-women-of-the-harlem-renaissance/">Harlem Renaissance</a>, a movement for black self-determination and cultural affirmation.</li>
<li>The creators of the Indian Arts and Crafts Board and <a href="https://www.doi.gov/iacb/indian-arts-and-crafts-act-1935">Act of 1935</a> protecting Native American cultural products and heritage.</li>
<li>The nation’s first <a href="http://pages.uoregon.edu/culturwk/culturework12.html">local arts councils</a> such as the <a href="http://www.quincy175.com/175-years-of-history/">Quincy, Illinois Society of Fine Arts</a> and the <a href="http://intothearts.org/about/">Winston-Salem Arts Council</a>, a <a href="http://special.lib.umn.edu/findaid/xml/sw0014.xml">case</a> of the arts utilized by the local <a href="https://archive.org/stream/juniorleagueofwi1951juni#page/12/mode/2up">Junior League</a> as a distraction from racial issues in the South.</li>
</ul>
<p><a name="Note2"></a><br />
2. Looking at the rate of consumer spending on performing arts experiences (a somewhat problematic proxy for arts engagement, but one of the only ones available for some earlier period) sheds some light on how Americans’ participation rates have changed over time. In their landmark 1966 book <i>Performing Arts: The Economic Dilemma, </i>economists Baumol and Bowen point out that even though it was popular in the press at the time to describe a cultural boom, the actual rate of spending on performing arts activities fell 25% between 1929 and 1963 when corrected for population growth, inflation, and economic growth, while spending on other cultural goods like sound recordings and sports grew during that time. A 2001 book by Heilbrun, <a href="https://books.google.com/books/about/The_Economics_of_Art_and_Culture.html?id=SWGhvkoI-i0C&amp;source=kp_cover">The Economics of Arts and Culture</a>, takes a similar tactic, looking at consumer spending on the performing arts as a percentage of total disposable income, effectively controlling for rises in the latter. There is evidence that the “cultural boom” that Baumol and Bowen had not found evidence for in the early 60s, was taking place from 1975 and 1990. In that period, the percentage of disposable income spent on the performing arts experienced a turn-around and began to rise. Heilbrun says, “After reaching a low of less than 7 cents per $100 of DPI [Disposable personal income] in the mid-1970s, consumer spending on the performing arts rose to 9.1 cents per $100 in 1980 and 13.4 cents in 1990&#8230; between 1975 and 1990 consumer expenditure on the performing arts increased almost exactly twice as fast as DPI.” (21) In fact, it rose even faster than the percentage of spending on motion pictures and sporting events. Heilbrun posits that this is a result of the subsidies made available in the 1950s and 1960s through the nonprofit ecosystem. These funds enabled to the creation (or expansion) of nonprofit arts institutions outside of major cities, where large numbers of arts organizations were not supportable by consumer spending (or even local wealthy patrons) alone. The new participation opportunities these groups offered met “latent demand” in these new geographic areas. Heilbrun does note that rising ticket prices are likely also a part of this overall increase in spending, especially after 1985.<br />
<a name="Note3"></a><br />
3. Researchers sometimes examine the division between nonprofit and commercial activity in the arts as a way to isolate the effects of nonprofit status. In both <a href="https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/23.pdf">1982 </a>and <a href="https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/63.pdf">1992</a> the NEA performed such an analysis on performing arts organizations. Within the list of states with higher rates of commercial performing arts activities, it&#8217;s easy to recognize the influence of industries which do not depend on reaching local audiences, like the music and film industries in Nashville Los Angeles. Even commercial hubs which do provide person experiences like Las Vegas and New York, are made possibly and marketed toward large numbers of tourists. These numbers demonstrate that the nonprofit infrastructure has been an important factor when it comes to providing live artistic experiences in areas without a large influx of travelers.<br />
<a name="Note4"></a><br />
4. In his 2006 study “The Intersectoral Division of Labor in the Arts,” Paul DiMaggio looks at the division of nonprofit and commercial arts by discipline, using data from the US Economic Census from 1997. One striking divide is between disciplines that have been historically considered more prestigious like museums and orchestras (almost entirely nonprofit), and disciplines that are more recently recognized for their artistic merits like jazz and ethnic dance (more predominantly commercial). While one could make the argument that jazz and ethnic dance are inherently more commercially viable, it seems more likely that they are in fact, inherently more difficult to find subsidy for within the nonprofit infrastructure. Dimaggio does note that the creation of the NEA and other state and local government funding sources did help to expand the narrowness of the early funding efforts in the 1960s, though the predominance of high culture in the nonprofit sphere remains.<br />
<a name="Note5"></a><br />
5. The vibrant yet flawed nonprofit arts ecology we have today exists thanks to individuals and groups who have challenged, spread, diversified, and redefined the sector in the last half century. Some of these agents of change include:</p>
<ul>
<li><a href="http://newsdesk.si.edu/about/bios/claudine-brown">Claudine Brown</a>, Assistant Secretary for Education and Access for the Smithsonian Institution, former director of the National African American Museum Project and the arts and culture program at the Nathan Cummings Foundation, and former instructor to many of today’s “managers at art, history, natural history, science and children’s museums throughout the country.”</li>
<li><a href="http://www.fundinguniverse.com/company-histories/alvin-ailey-dance-foundation-inc-history/">Judith Jamison</a>, who alongside others brought financial stability to the <a href="http://www.alvinailey.org/about/history">Alvin Ailey American Dance Theater</a> through increased funding, novel corporate agreements, and a 50th anniversary campaign that grew the endowment to $50 million, carrying forward Ailey’s visionary company which “changed forever the perception of American dance.”</li>
<li>The politically motivated, important artists of the <a href="http://www.blackpast.org/aah/black-arts-movement-1965-1975">Black Arts Movement</a> (1965-1975).</li>
<li><a href="https://www.arts.gov/article/live-lincoln-center-brings-arts-airwaves">John Goberman</a>, creator and executive producer of <i>Live from Lincoln Center</i>. “We have discovered that television, far from undermining live performances, whets the viewer’s appetite for more” (<a href="https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/NEA-Annual-Report-1980.pdf">NEA Annual Report 1980</a>).</li>
<li><a href="http://bit.ly/1Kr00Du">The Apollo</a>, which switched to nonprofit status in 1991.</li>
<li>Karen Finley, Tim Miller, Holly Hughes, and John Fleck aka the <a href="http://articles.latimes.com/1990-08-25/entertainment/ca-998_1_performance-artists">“NEA Four”</a> who filed suit when their NEA grants were vetoed in 1990, even after passing peer-review panels. The case caused the NEA to eliminate grants to individual artists in 1994.</li>
<li><a href="http://www.asianwomengivingcircle.org/about-1.html">Asian Women&#8217;s Giving Circle</a>, the first and largest giving circle in the nation led by Asian American women, promoting grassroots philanthropy.</li>
<li><a href="http://www.philasun.com/local/african-american-museum-in-phila-elects-claire-lomax-as-board-chair/">Claire Lomax Esq.</a>, CEO of the Lomax Family Foundation, one of the nation’s leaders in <a href="http://foundationcenter.org/getstarted/topical/african.html">black philanthropy</a>.</li>
<li><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franny_Armstrong">Franny Armstrong</a> who in 2004 was one of the first artists to use an online donation system for her work, a feature film entitled <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Age_of_Stupid">The Age of Stupid</a>.</li>
<li>Dr. Robert Gumbiner who left the <a href="http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/culturemonster/2009/03/molaa-gets-25-m.html">Museum of Latin American Art</a> with a $25 million endowment upon his death in 2009.</li>
</ul>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h2>FULL BIBLIOGRAPHY</h2>
<p>Anderson, J. (1993, June 7). W. McNeil Lowry Is Dead; Patron of the Arts Was 80. <i>The New York Times</i>. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/1993/06/07/obituaries/w-mcneil-lowry-is-dead-patron-of-the-arts-was-80.html">http://www.nytimes.com/1993/06/07/obituaries/w-mcneil-lowry-is-dead-patron-of-the-arts-was-80.html</a></p>
<p>Bennett, J. T. (2016). <i>Subsidizing Culture: Taxpayer Enrichment of the Creative Class</i>. Transaction Publishers.</p>
<p>Binkiewicz, D. M. (2009). Directions in Arts Policy History. <i>Journal of Policy History</i>, <i>21</i>(4), 424–430.</p>
<p>Blau, J. R. (1991). The Disjunctive History of U.S. Museums, 1869-1980. <i>Social Forces</i>, <i>70</i>(1), 87–105. <a href="http://doi.org/10.2307/2580063">http://doi.org/10.2307/2580063</a></p>
<p>National Center for Charitable Statistics. (2015) Business Master File.. Retrieved January 3, 2016, from <a href="http://nccsweb.urban.org/tablewiz/bmf.php">http://nccsweb.urban.org/tablewiz/bmf.php</a></p>
<p>Bogaert, S., Boone, C., Negro, G., &amp; Witteloostuijn, A. van. (2014). Organizational Form Emergence A Meta-Analysis of the Ecological Theory of Legitimation. <i>Journal of Management</i>, 0149206314527129. <a href="http://doi.org/10.1177/0149206314527129">http://doi.org/10.1177/0149206314527129</a></p>
<p>Burns, J. S. (1975). <i>The Awkward Embrace: The Creative Artist and the Institution in America</i> (1st edition). New York: Alfred A. Knopf.</p>
<p>Chartrand, H. H. (2000). Toward an American arts industry. <i>The Public Life of the Arts in America</i>, 22–49.</p>
<p>Cherbo, J. M., &amp; Wyszomirski, M. J. (2000). <i>The Public Life of the Arts in America</i>. Rutgers University Press.</p>
<p>Clayton, Lord. (2015). Arts &amp; America: 1780-2015. In <i>Arts &amp; America</i> (pp. 1–36). Americans for the Arts.</p>
<p>Cultural economics: the arts, the heritage and the media industries. Volume 2. (1997).</p>
<p>DiMaggio, P. J. (1984). The Nonprofit Instrument and the Influence of the Marketplace on Policies in the Arts. In <i>The Arts and Public Policy in the United States</i> (pp. 57 – 99). Prentice-Hall.</p>
<p>DiMaggio, P. J. (2006). Nonprofit organizations and the intersectoral division of labor in the arts. In W. W. Powell &amp; Ri. Steinberg (Eds.), <i>The nonprofit sector: A research handbook</i> (2nd ed.). Yale University Press.</p>
<p>DiMaggio, P. J., &amp; Anheier, H. K. (1990). The Sociology of Nonprofit Organizations and Sectors. <i>Annual Review of Sociology</i>, <i>16</i>, 137–159.</p>
<p>O’Quinn, J. (2005). Going National: How America’s Regional Theatre Movement Changed the Game. Theatre Communications Group. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.americantheatre.org/2015/06/16/going-national-how-americas-regional-theatre-movement-changed-the-game/" target="_blank">http://www.americantheatre.org/2015/06/16/going-national-how-americas-regional-theatre-movement-changed-the-game/</a></p>
<p>Gray, C. M., &amp; Heilbrun, J. (2000). Economics of the Nonprofit Arts. <i>The Public Life of the Arts in America</i>, 202.</p>
<p>Hall, C. (1983, January 10). Nancy Hanks’ Gentle Persuasion. <i>The Washington Post</i>. Retrieved from <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/lifestyle/1983/01/10/nancy-hanks-gentle-persuasion/b6b3b39e-7505-404b-9732-75e29a2baee5/">https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/lifestyle/1983/01/10/nancy-hanks-gentle-persuasion/b6b3b39e-7505-404b-9732-75e29a2baee5/</a></p>
<p>Hall, P. D. (2001). <i>“ Inventing the Nonprofit Sector” and Other Essays on Philanthropy, Voluntarism, and Nonprofit Organizations</i>. JHU Press.</p>
<p>Hall, P. D. (2005). Historical perspectives on nonprofit organizations in the United States. <i>The Jossey-Bass Handbook of Nonprofit Leadership and Management</i>, <i>2</i>, 3–38.</p>
<p>Hall, P. D. (2006). A historical overview of philanthropy, voluntary associations, and nonprofit organizations in the United States, 1600–2000. <i>The Nonprofit Sector: A Research Handbook</i>, <i>2</i>, 32–65.</p>
<p>Hammack, D. C. (2002). Nonprofit Organizations in American History Research Opportunities and Sources. <i>American Behavioral Scientist</i>, <i>45</i>(11), 1638–1674. <a href="http://doi.org/10.1177/0002764202045011004" target="_blank">http://doi.org/10.1177/0002764202045011004</a></p>
<p>Hanks, N. (1965). <i>The Performing Arts: Problems and Prospects. Rockefeller Brothers’ Panel Report on the Future of Theatre, Dance, Music in America.</i> Rockefeller Brothers’ Fund. Retrieved from <a href="http://images.library.wisc.edu/Arts/EFacs/ArtsSoc/ArtsSocv03i3/reference/arts.artssocv03i3.rockefeller.pdf">http://images.library.wisc.edu/Arts/EFacs/ArtsSoc/ArtsSocv03i3/reference/arts.artssocv03i3.rockefeller.pdf</a></p>
<p>Heilbrun, J., &amp; Gray, C. M. (1993). <i>The economics of art and culture: an American perspective</i>. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.</p>
<p>Heilbrun, J., &amp; Gray, C. M. (2001). <i>The Economics of Art and Culture</i> (Second). New York: Cambridge University Press.</p>
<p>Ivey, B. (2005). America needs a new system for supporting the arts. <i>Chronicle of Higher Education</i>, <i>51</i>(22), B6–B9. Retrieved from www.vanderbilt.edu/curbcenter/cms-wp/wp-content/uploads/Ivey_New_Approach_to_Funding_the_Arts.pdf</p>
<p>Kreidler, J. (1996). Leverage Lost: The Nonprofit Arts in the Post-Ford Era. <i>The Journal of Arts Management, Law, and Society</i>, <i>26</i>(2), 79–100. <a href="http://doi.org/10.1080/10632921.1996.9942956" target="_blank">http://doi.org/10.1080/10632921.1996.9942956</a></p>
<p>Lowry, W. M. (Ed.). (1984). <i>The Arts and Public Policy in the United States</i>. The American Assembly.</p>
<p>Maier, F., Meyer, M., &amp; Steinbereithner, M. (2014). Nonprofit Organizations Becoming Business-Like A Systematic Review. <i>Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly</i>. <a href="http://doi.org/10.1177/0899764014561796" target="_blank">http://doi.org/10.1177/0899764014561796</a></p>
<p>McCarthy, K. D. (1984). American Cultural Philanthropy: Past, Present, and Future. <i>Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science</i>, <i>471</i>, 13–26.</p>
<p>McNeil Lowry, W. (2003). The Arts and Philanthrophy: Motives that prompt the philanthropic act. <i>GIA Reader</i>, <i>14</i>(3). Retrieved from <a href="http://www.giarts.org/article/arts-and-philanthrophy" target="_blank">http://www.giarts.org/article/arts-and-philanthrophy</a></p>
<p>Nadel, N. (1977, September 22). Nancy Hanks Leaving Mark on the Arts. <i>The Pittsburgh Press</i>, p. A18. Pittsburgh, PA.</p>
<p>Nancy Hanks Facts. (n.d.). In <i>YourDictionary</i>. LoveToKnow Corporation. Retrieved from <a href="http://biography.yourdictionary.com/nancy-hanks#7JDbVG307utbjwsS.99">http://biography.yourdictionary.com/nancy-hanks#7JDbVG307utbjwsS.99</a></p>
<p>National Endowment of the Arts. (1998). <i>Count of Performing Arts Organizations Up by Over 30 %, 1987 &#8211; 1992</i> (Research Division Notes No. 62). Retrieved from <a href="https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/62.pdf">https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/62.pdf</a></p>
<p>National Endowment for the Arts. (1998). <i>The Performing Arts Spread Out: Geography of Performing Arts Organizations, 1992</i> (Note # 63). Retrieved from <a href="https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/63.pdf" target="_blank">https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/63.pdf</a></p>
<p>National Endowment of the Arts. (2013). <i>Birth and mortality rates of arts and cultural organizations (ACOs), 1990-2010</i>. Washington, D.C. Retrieved from <a href="https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/Research-Art-Works-Harvard.pdf" target="_blank">https://www.arts.gov/sites/default/files/Research-Art-Works-Harvard.pdf</a></p>
<p>Novick, R. (2011). Please, Don’t Start a Theatre Company! Next Generation Arts Institutions and Alternate Career Paths. <i>GIA Reader</i>, <i>22</i>(1). Retrieved from <a href="http://www.giarts.org/article/please-dont-start-theater-company" target="_blank">http://www.giarts.org/article/please-dont-start-theater-company</a></p>
<p>O’Neill, M. (2002). <i>Nonprofit Nation: A New Look at the Third America</i>. John Wiley &amp; Sons.</p>
<p>Peterson, B. (1996). <i>The changing faces of tradition : a report on the folk and traditional arts in the United States /</i>. Washington, DC : National Endowment for the Arts.</p>
<p>Powell, W. W., &amp; Steinberg, R. (2006). <i>The Nonprofit Sector: A Research Handbook</i>. Yale University Press.</p>
<p>Ragsdale, D. (2011, May 16). L3C Cha-Cha-Cha. Retrieved from <a href="http://blog.americansforthearts.org/2011/05/16/l3c-cha-cha-cha" target="_blank">http://blog.americansforthearts.org/2011/05/16/l3c-cha-cha-cha</a></p>
<p>Saxon, W. (1983, January 8). NANCY HANKS DEAD AT 55; HEADED NATIONAL ARTS GROUP. <i>The New York Times</i>. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/1983/01/08/obituaries/nancy-hanks-dead-at-55-headed-national-arts-group.html">http://www.nytimes.com/1983/01/08/obituaries/nancy-hanks-dead-at-55-headed-national-arts-group.html</a></p>
<p>Straight, M. (1988). <i>Nancy Hanks, An Intimate Portrait: The Creation of a National Commitment to the Arts</i> (1st edition). Durham N.C.: Duke University Press Books.</p>
<p>Sussmann, L. (1984). Anatomy of the Dance Company Boom, 1958-1980. <i>Dance Research Journal</i>, <i>16</i>(2), 23–28. <a href="http://doi.org/10.2307/1478719" target="_blank">http://doi.org/10.2307/1478719</a></p>
<p>Wyszomirski, M. (1999). Philanthropy and Culture: Patterns, context, and change. In <i>Philanthropy and the Nonprofit Sector in a Changing America</i> (pp. 461–479). Bloomington, Indiana: Indiana University Press.</p>
<p>Wyszomirski, M. J. (2013). Shaping a triple-bottom line for nonprofit arts organizations: Micro-, macro-, and meta-policy influences. <i>Cultural Trends</i>, <i>22</i>(3/4), 156–166. <a href="http://doi.org/10.1080/09548963.2013.817645">http://doi.org/10.1080/09548963.2013.817645</a></p>
<h3>GIF Animation Photo Credit</h3>
<p>LC-USZC4-6410: American Revolution. Evacuation of Boston by the British, by National Museum of the U.S. Navy <a href="https://flic.kr/p/sxjuD6">https://flic.kr/p/sxjuD6</a></p>
<p>Confederate Possession in Civil War America by Victoria Wynn <a href="https://flic.kr/p/vVPyXJ">https://flic.kr/p/vVPyXJ</a></p>
<p>&#8220;U.S. Is Voted Dry.&#8221; by Thomas Cizauskas <a href="https://flic.kr/p/Cfa2Cd">https://flic.kr/p/Cfa2Cd</a></p>
<p>Dance to the Duke by StudioMONDO <a href="https://flic.kr/p/pv3Ddh">https://flic.kr/p/pv3Ddh</a></p>
<p>Harlem club map from 1930s detail by Rik Panganiban <a href="https://flic.kr/p/8toWkh">https://flic.kr/p/8toWkh</a></p>
<p>Fairfax Bomber Factory worker on B-25 by Sms_S <a href="https://flic.kr/p/DJDzc5">https://flic.kr/p/DJDzc5</a></p>
<p>1950s wood panel on a Ford Country Squire by Mr. Gray <a href="https://flic.kr/p/DumSR5">https://flic.kr/p/DumSR5</a></p>
]]></content:encoded>
			<wfw:commentRss>https://createquity.com/2016/03/notes-to-who-will-be-the-next-arts-revolutionary/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
		<slash:comments>0</slash:comments>
			<dc:creator><![CDATA[Katie Ingersoll]]></dc:creator>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Feldman]]></dc:creator>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Talia Gibas]]></dc:creator>
	</item>
		<item>
		<title>Part of Your World: On the Arts and Wellbeing</title>
		<link>https://createquity.com/2015/08/part-of-your-world-on-the-arts-and-wellbeing/</link>
		<comments>https://createquity.com/2015/08/part-of-your-world-on-the-arts-and-wellbeing/#comments</comments>
		<pubDate>Mon, 31 Aug 2015 15:22:45 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Talia Gibas, Ian David Moss, John Carnwath, Katie Ingersoll and Fari Nzinga]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[Features]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Amartya Sen]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[capability approach]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[indicators]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Martha Nussbaum]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[quality of life]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[wellbeing]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[wellbeing index]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://createquity.com/?p=8153</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[A concept that's been making the rounds in other fields for decades provides fresh ideas about how to think about the benefits of the arts.]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<h2>SUMMARY:</h2>
<ul>
<li><b>A large and emerging literature on the topic of wellbeing</b> has a lot to teach us about the arts&#8217; role in society.</li>
<li><b>Wellbeing is a way of grouping the various components of individual and societal health under a single conceptual umbrella.</b> This is important because it opens up the possibility of understanding the relative value or benefit of those components as part of an integrated whole instead of treating them as completely separate.</li>
<li><b>A number of large-scale international economic and social policy initiatives are grounded in wellbeing</b>, including much of the global development work undertaken by the United Nations.</li>
<li>Most wellbeing definitions do not explicitly include culture, but some do. In particular, a variation of a wellbeing framework called the <b>capability approach</b> recognizes the capacity for imagination and play as critical components of human wellbeing.</li>
<li>Describing the benefits and costs of arts ecosystem outcomes in the language of wellbeing <b>could earn the field a proper seat at the table in conversations about human progress </b>without downplaying the so-called &#8220;intrinsic&#8221; benefits of the arts.</li>
</ul>
<p style="text-align: center;">* * *</p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><span id="more-8153"></span></p>
<div id="attachment_8161" style="width: 650px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/eCTZF1"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-8161" class="wp-image-8161 size-full" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/8950176562_8bbd238321_z.jpg" alt="8950176562_8bbd238321_z" width="640" height="360" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/8950176562_8bbd238321_z.jpg 640w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/8950176562_8bbd238321_z-300x169.jpg 300w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, 640px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-8161" class="wp-caption-text">Photo by Flickr user Tim Jordan. Creative Commons license.</p></div>
<p>Quick! What’s the most important issue in the arts? Is it declining audiences? The fact that it’s so hard to make a living as an artist? Changing demographics and cultural equity? Unsustainable business models? New technologies? Government funding? Arts education? Gentrification? Creative placemaking? Where I can go to figure out what the heck I’m doing this Friday night?</p>
<p>Spend any time reading up on arts policy and philanthropy or attending conferences in the arts, and you’ll see plenty of attention devoted to all of these topics and more. To be sure, all of them have implications for the future of arts and culture in the United States, not to mention the rest of the world. The challenge is, with so many issues to track, and no way of comparing them to each other, we can’t know how to prioritize our limited energies in the areas that are going to make the most difference. We can’t even be sure that the biggest problems or opportunities in the sector are on our collective radar at all. What if the most impactful thing we could do is something that no one’s talking about?</p>
<p>At Createquity, we are trying to tackle that conundrum head-on by framing our work in terms of the broad language of social good and human progress. In this way we sometimes think of ourselves as a cause-specific analogue to the <a href="https://centreforeffectivealtruism.org/">effective altruism movement</a>, which tries to identify the highest-leverage opportunities to do the most good with the resources available to us, whatever they might be. Accordingly, when we developed our <a href="https://createquity.com/about/a-healthy-arts-ecosystem/">definition of a healthy arts ecosystem</a>, we declared that all of the conditions and outcomes named in that definition should be understood in the broader context of “improving people’s lives in concrete and meaningful ways.” While that names a single yardstick of “life improvement” to measure every success against, without further elaborating on what it actually means to improve someone’s life, the concept is not very useful in practice. Fortunately, many smart people have been grappling with the same problem and have made significant strides towards adding specificity around such terms in recent decades. Our investigation of their work has led us to an exciting and emerging literature on the topic of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Well-being"><b>wellbeing</b></a>, a literature with roots in multiple fields outside of the arts.</p>
<div id="attachment_8183" style="width: 501px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/9J42FX"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-8183" class="wp-image-8183" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/5726737993_5c0c7d3d9f_z.jpg" alt="5726737993_5c0c7d3d9f_z" width="491" height="327" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/5726737993_5c0c7d3d9f_z.jpg 640w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/5726737993_5c0c7d3d9f_z-300x200.jpg 300w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 491px) 100vw, 491px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-8183" class="wp-caption-text">Logo of the World Health Organization by United States Mission Geneva. Creative Commons license.</p></div>
<h1><strong>WELLBEING 101</strong></h1>
<p>While no consensus definition of wellbeing exists, broadly speaking, it is a way of holistically grouping the many components of individual and societal health under a single conceptual umbrella. The intellectual origins of wellbeing date back more than half a century to 1948, when the World Health Organization <a href="http://www.who.int/about/definition/en/print.html">framed its definition of health</a> not only in terms of the absence of troublesome physical symptoms, but also in terms of the presence of certain attributes that suggested “physical, mental, and social well-being.” This was a departure from the prevalent medical conception of health at the time, which narrowly focused on the presence or absence of disease and categories of ailments in individuals.</p>
<p>Before long, this holistic perspective began to infiltrate the study of whole communities and societies. An early theoretical <a href="https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/social-indicators">work on “social indicators”</a> in the United States was undertaken by Harvard Business School professor Raymond Bauer in the mid-1960s and sponsored (surprisingly enough) by NASA. With a large and visible public investment to protect, the space agency asked Bauer to quantify its effects on American life, but the professor concluded that the effort would not get far without an established way to quantify improvements to social conditions. To bridge that gap, Bauer and his co-authors pioneered the idea and early methods of developing statistical measures of social values and goals.</p>
<p>Bauer’s work coincided with a growing backlash against the then-commonplace use of economic measures such as <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gross_domestic_product">Gross Domestic Product</a> (GDP) to measure social progress in the national and international policy arena. While GDP is a broadly accepted way to measure the size of an economy, it is <a href="http://www.neweconomyworkinggroup.org/visions/living-wealth-indicators/gdp-flawed-measure-progress">at best a flawed proxy</a> for the outcomes that really signify how well societies are faring. In one of the more remarkable developments in the history of political economy, the teenage King Jigme Wangchuk of the small nation of Bhutan <a href="http://www.gnhcentrebhutan.org/what-is-gnh/the-story-of-gnh/">coined the term “Gross National Happiness”</a> as a replacement for GDP in 1972. (Decades later, a fleshed-out version of GNH is in active use in the country and <a href="http://www.grossnationalhappiness.com/9-domains/good-governance-and-gross-national-happiness/">enshrined in its Constitution</a>.) Around the same time, Richard Easterlin’s <a href="http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2008/04/16/business/Easterlin1974.pdf">research on happiness levels in post-war Europe</a> in suggested that increased material abundance did not necessarily yield increased happiness, which helped launch the field of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Happiness_economics">happiness economics</a>. By 2008, when the French government brought together a <a href="http://www.wikiprogress.org/index.php/Commission_on_the_Measurement_of_Economic_Performance_and_Social_Progress">star-studded international panel of economists</a> led by Nobel Prize winners Joseph E. Stiglitz and Amartya Sen to try to move beyond GDP once and for all, wellbeing was rapidly establishing itself as the dominant theoretical foundation of the global policy arena. The resulting <a href="http://archives.cerium.ca/IMG/pdf/1-Measurement.pdf">Stiglitz-Sen-Fitoussi Commission report</a> is considered a major watershed in the mainstreaming of wellbeing.</p>
<p>Today, a large and growing field of study is devoted to wellbeing and its measurement, with its own <a href="http://link.springer.com/journal/11205">peer-reviewed journals</a>, leading experts, and esoteric controversies. Given that wellbeing scholars operate at the intersection of a number of different fields, it’s not surprising that the lexicon can sometimes get messy, with terms such as <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quality_of_life">quality of life</a>, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_of_living">standard of living</a>, and <a href="http://www.sustainablecommunities.gov/mission/livability-principles">livability</a> variously standing in for the idea of a holistic measure of individual and community health. One of the more notable debates has centered around objective vs. subjective ways of conceptualizing wellbeing. Historically, a Scandinavian <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/20629948?seq=1#page_scan_tab_contents">school of thought</a> relied on living conditions such as income and physical health that can be observed directly, while an American <a href="https://www.russellsage.org/publications/quality-american-life">“quality of life” approach</a> focused on “subjective wellbeing” (i.e., asking people about their happiness, agency, and satisfaction with life). Advocates of the latter argue that subjective wellbeing is the most direct measure of an individual’s lived experience. Defining wellbeing solely in subjective terms may not tell the whole story, however, since people&#8217;s expectations for their own wellbeing may be affected by their context and past experiences. For example, individuals in societies with relative deprivation may rate their subjective wellbeing higher because their basis for comparison is different than people in relatively well-off societies, or a drug addict might report being very happy in the moment despite not leading a healthy life overall. These days, there is <a href="http://www.oecd.org/statistics/oecd-guidelines-on-measuring-subjective-well-being-9789264191655-en.htm">widespread agreement</a> that a mix of objective and subjective measures is likely to provide the best understanding of wellbeing.</p>
<h1><b>THE CAPABILITY APPROACH AND THE RISE OF INDICATOR SYSTEMS<br />
</b></h1>
<p>The insight that neither objective nor subjective measures fully describe wellbeing on their own raises an important question: how does one account for people’s <i>differing abilities or desires</i> to make use of the resources provided them? Beginning in the 1980s, economist Amartya Sen began addressing this dilemma in earnest. His <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capability_approach"><b>capability approach</b></a>, refined in subsequent decades with philosopher Martha Nussbaum, frames wellbeing through the lens of social justice, taking the unique circumstances and choices of individuals into account. Among other things, the capability approach notes that:</p>
<div id="attachment_8165" style="width: 224px" class="wp-caption alignright"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/83FKPD"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-8165" class="wp-image-8165" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/4624887151_b38b0f1c00_z.jpg" alt="4624887151_b38b0f1c00_z" width="214" height="321" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/4624887151_b38b0f1c00_z.jpg 426w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/4624887151_b38b0f1c00_z-200x300.jpg 200w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 214px) 100vw, 214px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-8165" class="wp-caption-text">Amartya Sen. Photo by Flickr user Stefano Corso. Creative Commons license.</p></div>
<ul>
<li><b>Individuals draw varying levels of benefit from the same resources. </b>As a result, assessing wellbeing is much more complex than considering whether and how resources are distributed. It’s one thing to say, for example, that food is available to a particular population; it’s quite another to consider whether that food can actually nourish and sustain a pregnant woman or someone who is allergic to some of its core ingredients. As a result, the capability approach pays more attention to <b>specific states of being </b>(e.g., being nourished) <b>and activities </b>(e.g., learning) than to external inputs.</li>
<li><b>Having the freedom to make choices matters. </b>Whether or not people take advantage of the opportunities they have, their ability to make decisions about how they pursue their lives is vital to wellbeing. The physical state of a person who is starving may be similar to that of someone who is fasting, but the right of the latter to <i>choose </i>his/her condition in an informed manner is crucial. Through this lens, all human beings must have the knowledge, skills, and opportunity to lead a meaningful life &#8212; beyond mere survival, a life “<a href="https://books.google.com/books?id=urJ9RFfjUzQC&amp;pg=PA159&amp;lpg=PA159&amp;dq=%E2%80%9Ca+life+that+they+have+reason+to+value%E2%80%9D+%28Sen,+1999%29&amp;source=bl&amp;ots=FX97xP3uKn&amp;sig=RZe7c0AAxvzrJYVLdMiMWi3ups8&amp;hl=en&amp;sa=X&amp;ved=0CB8Q6AEwAGoVChMIk8Wu8NuIxwIV0aSICh0e7gYF#v=onepage&amp;q=%E2%80%9Ca%20life%20that%20they%20have%20reason%20to%20value%E2%80%9D%20(Sen%2C%201999)&amp;f=false">that they have reason to value</a>.” Having the “capability” to achieve various states is therefore more significant than whether or not one actually achieves them.</li>
</ul>
<p>Economists and international development scholars were quick to seize on Sen’s capability approach in their quest to break from an over-reliance on the GDP. As disillusioned as they were with standard macroeconomic measures, they knew that <a href="http://www.researchgate.net/journal/0303-8300_Social_Indicators_Research">alternative metrics were needed</a> in order for wellbeing to serve as a viable replacement. This gap led to a demand for new <b>indicator systems</b> that researchers and policymakers could use to translate quality of life into something that could be measured. Indicators, as they saw it, were necessary for wellbeing to move beyond a theoretical construct into something with practical significance. Beyond providing a means to count whether certain conditions are present, indicators could inform judgments about the success or failure of particular policy decisions, be used to hold people in power accountable to the impact of their work, and provide a common vocabulary by which nations, regions, or specific groups of people can track how they are faring.</p>
<p>In 1990, the United Nations Development Programme (UDNP), led by Pakistani scholar Mahbub ul Haq, began producing Human Development Reports <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Development_Index#Origins">meant to</a> “shift the focus of development economics from national income accounting to people-centered policies.” In the process, they worked on a numerical index that could capture non-economic elements of wellbeing. Amartya Sen was involved; while he initially fretted that the capability approach was too complex to be boiled down to numbers, Haq and others eventually convinced him that policymakers would only take the capability approach seriously if a single index number was provided. Thus, the <a href="http://hdr.undp.org/en/content/human-development-index-hdi">Human Development Index</a> (HDI) was born.</p>
<p><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="aligncenter size-full wp-image-8154" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/HDI.png" alt="HDI" width="518" height="123" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/HDI.png 518w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/HDI-300x71.png 300w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 518px) 100vw, 518px" /></p>
<p>The HDI is relatively simple. Its three dimensions are “a long and healthy life,” “being knowledgeable,” and a “decent standard of living.” The indicators are life expectancy at birth, mean years of schooling for adults over 25 and expected years of schooling for young children (calculated via a mix of UNESCO statistics and actual enrollment figures), and gross national income per capita. The geometric mean of numerical scores from these four indicators comprise the final HDI index score for any particular country.</p>
<p>The United States fares quite well under this system, ranking fifth out of 187 nations in 2012-13. UNDP’s <b>Inequality-Adjusted Human Development Index</b> (IHDI), however, tells a different story. It adjusts the HDI score based on the extent to which resources are more available to certain segments of the population than to others. (It uses a <a href="http://hdr.undp.org/sites/default/files/list_of_surveys_used_for_estimation_of_2013_ihdi.pdf">long list of surveys</a>, including a few distributed by the World Bank and European Union, to do this.) A country with perfect equality would have identical HDI and IHDI scores. Across all countries in the survey, however, scores are adjusted by an average of 22%. Under IHDI, the United States’s ranking falls by <i>more than twenty</i>, while the remaining countries in the top five either hold their spots or shift by one or two.</p>
<p>The Human Development Index is just one example of a number of impressive, large-scale wellbeing indicator systems that have been developed in recent years. Below are a few of the more interesting and/or well-known efforts:</p>
<p><a href="http://www.well-beingindex.com/"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="aligncenter wp-image-8155" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Gallup.png" alt="Gallup" width="338" height="95" /></a></p>
<p><a href="http://www.well-beingindex.com/"><b>Gallup-Healthways Wellbeing Index</b></a></p>
<p>Claiming to be the “most proven, mature, and comprehensive measure of well-being in the world,” the Gallup-Healthways Wellbeing Index was unveiled in 2008 as a high-profile partnership between an international health care provider and arguably the best-known public opinion polling firm in the United States. Dubbed the “Dow Jones of health,” the index has a national and international version. The former measures life evaluation, physical health, emotional health, healthy behavior, work environment, and basic access via a 55-question survey distributed to 1,000 Americans <i>per day</i>. Its ultimate <a href="http://www.gallup.com/file/poll/125963/Gallup-Healthways_Well-Being_Index_Press_Release_4-28-08_final.pdf">ambitions</a> are to be “a daily measure determining the correlation between the places where people work and the communities in which they live, and how that and other factors impact their well-being.” The international edition is more modest, measuring five factors (purpose, social, financial, community, and physical) via ten specific questions included in Gallup’s World Poll, a monster survey that claims to represent 95% of the global population. Its reliance on self-reported perceptions of wellbeing sets it apart from other wellbeing indicators, and the impact of this difference in approach is notable: top Gallup-Healthways performers include a number of Latin American nations and territories such as Panama, Costa Rica, Puerto Rico, Belize, Chile, and Guatemala that don’t tend to rank highly in the other indices.</p>
<p><a href="http://www.socialprogressimperative.org/data/spi"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="aligncenter wp-image-8156" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Screen-Shot-2015-08-07-at-6.49.44-PM.png" alt="Screen Shot 2015-08-07 at 6.49.44 PM" width="436" height="212" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Screen-Shot-2015-08-07-at-6.49.44-PM.png 1005w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Screen-Shot-2015-08-07-at-6.49.44-PM-300x146.png 300w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 436px) 100vw, 436px" /></a></p>
<p><b><a href="http://www.socialprogressimperative.org/data/spi">Social Progress Index</a><br />
</b><b>The Social Progress Imperative</b></p>
<p>Billed as a “holistic, 21st century assessment of the health of society,” the <a href="http://www.socialprogressimperative.org">Social Progress Imperative</a> was launched six years ago by the World Economic Forum’s Global Agenda Council on Philanthropy and Social Investing <a href="http://www.socialprogressimperative.org/about/origins">with the goal</a> of “spur[ring] competition between nations to improve the environment for social innovation in the way the [<a href="http://www.gaportal.org/global-indicators/global-competitiveness-index">Global Competitiveness Index</a>] has done for enablers of economic growth.” With seed funding from Fundación Avina and the Skoll Foundation, it launched its first research project, the Social Progress Index (SPI), in 2013. The SPI examines a whopping 54 environmental and and social indicators that fall under three broad dimensions: “basic human needs,” “foundations of wellbeing,” and “opportunity.” Unlike the HDI, the index does not take economic indicators like income into account, and also privileges outcomes (like the number of people who have access to clean water) over inputs (like policies aimed at increasing that access). Each dimension has four components that all have equal weight in determining the country’s overall score. Components include nutrition and medical care, access to knowledge, information, communications, and personal rights and freedoms. The Social Progress Imperative’s website breaks down each score with colors that indicate areas of relative strength and weakness when compared with other nations with similar GDP.</p>
<p><a href="http://www.oecdbetterlifeindex.org"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="aligncenter wp-image-8158" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/OECD.png" alt="OECD" width="213" height="312" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/OECD.png 314w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/OECD-204x300.png 204w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 213px) 100vw, 213px" /></a></p>
<p><a href="http://www.oecdbetterlifeindex.org/"><b>OECD Better Life Index<br />
</b></a><b>Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development</b></p>
<p>In contrast to the previous examples with their fixed metric definitions and weights, OECD’s Better Life Index allows website visitors to manipulate the data on the agency’s 34 member nations according to their own personal definition of wellbeing. The Better Life index was launched in 2011 to put decisions about the most important aspects of wellbeing into the hands of the public. It’s not an entire free-for-all; the Better Life Index has eleven discrete topics taken from OECD’s <a href="http://www.oecd.org/statistics/better-life-initiative.htm">other work on wellbeing indicators</a>, split between material living conditions (including housing, income, and jobs), and the more nebulous quality of life (which in this case includes measures of community, education, environment, governance, health, life satisfaction, safety and work/life balance). Each topic is measured in turn by anywhere from one to four indicators, which run the gamut of statistics from the chance of workers losing their jobs in the last year to self-reported life satisfaction. Wellbeing scores can be broken out by gender, and each user can save his/her personal index and compare it with those of others.</p>
<p>Other examples of wellbeing and quality of life indicator systems include the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercer_Quality_of_Living_Survey">Mercer Quality of Living Survey</a> and two products from the Economist Intelligence Unit: the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Economist_Intelligence_Unit%27s_liveability_survey">Global Liveability Survey</a> and the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Where-to-be-born_Index">Where-to-be-Born Index</a>. The last of these, which is based on life satisfaction, is notable for its use of regression analysis to determine the relative weights of the 11 factors that make up the index, in contrast to the equal or user-determined weighting seen elsewhere. The Mercer and Global Liveability surveys rank quality of life in individual cities rather than entire nations; Vienna and Melbourne, respectively, take the top spots.</p>
<h1><b>DESPERATELY SEEKING CULTURE?<br />
</b></h1>
<p>These and other wellbeing indicator systems typically break down the general concepts of wellbeing or quality of life into a number of discrete domains like economic prosperity, education, or health. The domains are most often developed by experts working from theoretical conceptions of wellbeing, though a few cases draw heavily from definitions generated by the population being studied. There are a number of variations in the details, but a <a href="http://bms.sagepub.com/content/71/1/58">review of more than 20 indicator systems by a group of researchers led by Michael R. Hagerty</a> identified seven domains that are common across nearly all instances:</p>
<ul>
<li>relationships with family and friends</li>
<li>emotional wellbeing</li>
<li>material wellbeing</li>
<li>health</li>
<li>work and productive activity</li>
<li>feeling a part of one&#8217;s local community</li>
<li>personal safety</li>
</ul>
<p>You’ll note the absence of arts and culture from this list. In part, that’s because different societies have dramatically different ideas about what those words mean, and internationally comparable data sources relevant to culture are all but nonexistent. Robert Prescott-Allen, who in 2001 published a book <a href="http://www.amazon.com/The-Wellbeing-Nations-Country-By-Country-Environment/dp/1559638303">detailing his own indicator system</a> with an emphasis on the environmental impact of countries, originally set out to include culture as a top-level domain. Ultimately, he abandoned the idea, finding he could not identify cultural indicators that were consistent across a majority of nations included in his project.</p>
<p>Prescott-Allen is not alone; most indicator systems and other initiatives rooted in wellbeing have historically overlooked the role of arts and culture, and continue to do so. A recent <a href="http://www.agenda21culture.net/index.php/documents/culture-as-a-goal-in-post-2015">advocacy campaign</a> to integrate an explicit goal of cultural sustainability into the next iteration of the UN’s <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennium_Development_Goals">Millennium Development Goals</a> appears to have <a href="https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/7891Transforming%20Our%20World.pdf">failed</a>, despite <a href="http://www.unesco.org/new/fileadmin/MULTIMEDIA/HQ/CLT/images/FinalHangzhouDeclaration20130517.pdf">support from UNESCO itself</a> and significant investment on the part of that agency in an <a href="http://en.unesco.org/creativity/sites/creativity/files/digital-library/CDIS%20Methodology%20Manual_0.pdf">indicator system to track culture’s role in sustainable development</a>. Despite not achieving its primary objective, the advocacy campaign has yielded a <a href="http://www.culture2015goal.net/images/yootheme/culture2015/def/Indicators_ENG.pdf">useful set of ways to think about culture’s indirect contribution to wellbeing</a> through priorities such as poverty reduction, education, and good governance.</p>
<p>Even so, a handful of individual countries have developed indices of wellbeing that include culture as a top-level concern. The aforementioned <a href="http://www.grossnationalhappiness.com/">Gross National Happiness index</a> adopted by the government of Bhutan is one example. The “Cultural Diversity and Resilience” domain of the index includes measures such as fluency in one of the regional dialects of Bhutan, expertise in one of thirteen traditional Bhutanese crafts (e.g. weaving, embroidery, blacksmithing, bamboo works, paper making, etc.), and knowledge of DriglamNamzha (the “expected behaviour [of consuming, clothing, moving] especially in formal occasions and in formal spaces”). In North America, the <a href="https://uwaterloo.ca/canadian-index-wellbeing/">Canadian Index of Wellbeing</a> includes the broad category of culture and leisure, which includes measures of leisure time as well as participation in activities such as camping, sports, or performing arts.</p>
<p>Another notable exception comes from the capability approach, or at least one particular version of it. Although Amartya Sen refuses to endorse “<a href="http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/capability-approach/#SelAggCap">one pre-determined canonical list of capabilities</a>” for the capability approach, his partner in crime, the philosopher Martha Nussbaum, has had no such compunctions &#8212; and her definition includes multiple nods to arts and culture. <a href="https://createquity.com/2015/08/notes-to-part-of-your-world/#anchor1">[1]</a></p>
<p>In 2000, Nussbaum <a href="https://www.worldcat.org/search?qt=wikipedia&amp;q=isbn%3A9780521003858">published a list of “central human capabilities&#8221;</a> as follows:</p>
<ul>
<ul>
<ul>
<li>Life</li>
<li>Bodily Health</li>
<li>Bodily Integrity</li>
<li>Senses, Imagination, and Thought</li>
<li>Emotions</li>
<li>Practical Reason</li>
<li>Affiliation
<ul>
<li>living with and towards others</li>
<li>social bases of self-respect and non-humiliation</li>
</ul>
</li>
<li>Other Species</li>
<li>Play</li>
<li>Control Over One’s Environment
<ul>
<li>Political</li>
<li>Material</li>
</ul>
</li>
</ul>
</ul>
</ul>
<p>In her <a href="http://www.iep.utm.edu/sen-cap/#H7">explanation of this list</a>, Nussbaum draws the clearest ties to arts and culture through the two principles of “Senses, Imagination, and Thought” and “Play.” The former includes “being able to use imagination and thought in connection with experiencing and producing works and events of one’s own choice, religious, literary, musical, and so forth,” and the latter refers to “being able to laugh, to play, to enjoy recreational activities.”</p>
<div id="attachment_8167" style="width: 650px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/utqrCv"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-8167" class="wp-image-8167 size-full" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/16361073088_67ef22bfa7_z.jpg" alt="16361073088_67ef22bfa7_z" width="640" height="427" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/16361073088_67ef22bfa7_z.jpg 640w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/16361073088_67ef22bfa7_z-300x200.jpg 300w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, 640px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-8167" class="wp-caption-text">&#8220;Imagination&#8221; by Flickr user Thomas Hawk. Creative Commons license.</p></div>
<h1><b>PART OF Y/OUR WORLD<br />
</b></h1>
<p>Examining the connection between wellbeing and the arts <a href="https://createquity.com/2015/08/notes-to-part-of-your-world/#anchor2">[2]</a> promises to move Createquity’s work forward in two respects. First, it adds some clarity and definition to our rather vague notion of the “concrete and meaningful ways” in which the arts improve people’s lives. And second, it connects the ideas embedded in our healthy arts ecosystem definition to a rich and rapidly expanding body of literature, lending added legitimacy to our work and opening the door to a broader cross-sectoral dialogue. The former of these benefits comes into play whenever we find ourselves having to compare different problems, interventions, or opportunities within the arts ecosystem. Our previous framework of “improving lives in concrete and meaningful ways” was on the right track, but weak in that it left “improving” and “meaningful” undefined. While not completely solving that problem, jumping on the wellbeing bandwagon does allow us to hone in on a range of likely definitions for those terms. Put another way, this new lens clarifies that the conditions and outcomes generated by a healthy arts ecosystem must increase the net wellbeing of society in order to constitute meaningful improvement in people’s lives.</p>
<p>The second benefit is perhaps even more important than the first. Scholars, philanthropists, policymakers, and others have <a href="http://individual.utoronto.ca/diep/c/fullerton.pdf">long</a> <a href="http://theconversation.com/are-the-arts-and-culture-a-public-good-29939">struggled</a> to articulate how arts and culture fit into a broader conception of public goods and charitable aims, with the result that social innovation initiatives frequently treat the arts by different standards or ignore them entirely. Newer philanthropic movements such as effective altruism have sometimes demonstrated <a href="https://createquity.com/2013/12/uncomfortable-thoughts-are-we-missing-the-point-of-effective-altruism/">outright hostility to the arts</a>, associating them with headline-grabbing capital or endowment gifts to major universities and large museums. Naturally, that prompts angry and defensive responses from the arts world in turn. Crucially, this distrust and lack of understanding on both sides arises from the <b>absence of a common language with which to judge the value and success of initiatives across sectors.</b> If we can describe the benefits and costs of arts ecosystem outcomes using the language of wellbeing in a way that celebrates rather than subsumes the unique things that make the arts special, that would lay the groundwork for a dialogue about the role of arts and culture in human progress in which all sides have a genuine stake.</p>
<p>Overall, we find the capability approach to be the most effective bridge between our existing healthy ecosystem definition and the fast-growing scholarship on wellbeing. It is particularly worth noting that Martha Nussbaum’s take on the capability approach is the clearest example we’ve found of integrating what have been commonly understood as the “intrinsic” benefits of the arts, such as joy, captivation, etc., into a broader definition of wellbeing. <a href="https://createquity.com/2015/08/notes-to-part-of-your-world/#anchor3">[3]</a> This approach allows us to think of the arts as influencing overall wellbeing both directly, through developing the capabilities of Play and Senses, Imagination, and Thought, and indirectly through, for example, their impact on the capability of Bodily Health. Such a framework improves on the <a href="https://createquity.com/2009/07/arts-policy-library-gifts-of-muse/">traditional delineation of “intrinsic” and “instrumental” benefits of the arts</a> by proposing a consistent way to value both.</p>
<p>The capability approach is particularly helpful for clarifying what we mean when when we say that human beings today and in the future have “opportunities” to engage in certain types of arts participation. (The same could be said for other efforts in the arts field to “improve access to” things like arts engagement or arts education.) Its emphasis on personal choice and freedoms rather than behaviors suggests that a narrow focus on things like participation rates in an arts class or attendance figures at a concert hall cannot tell us much about wellbeing. Choosing <i>not</i> to engage in a specific arts activity or a long-term aesthetic pursuit can be a well-informed decision that yields greater wellbeing than would otherwise be the case. Likewise, the capability approach reminds us that providing people with access to resources is not enough; they must have the necessary training, skills, and agency to make use of them. This latter insight is consistent with the position that proactive steps should be taken to provide basic arts education opportunities to all, even if not everyone will choose to engage with the arts throughout their whole lives. For all these reasons, although they have not been as widely adopted as the capability approach in general, Nussbaum’s central human capabilities arguably offer a more compelling theoretical rationale for arts and culture’s inclusion in wellbeing than simply slapping arts participation indicators on top of a wellbeing measurement index.</p>
<div id="attachment_8168" style="width: 463px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/oY9trF"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-8168" class="wp-image-8168" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/15075225885_fdaa7d7d00_z.jpg" alt="15075225885_fdaa7d7d00_z" width="453" height="339" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/15075225885_fdaa7d7d00_z.jpg 640w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/15075225885_fdaa7d7d00_z-300x224.jpg 300w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 453px) 100vw, 453px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-8168" class="wp-caption-text">&#8220;Which way do we go?&#8221; by Flickr user yooperann. Creative Commons license.</p></div>
<h1><b>WHERE WE GO FROM HERE<br />
</b></h1>
<p>It’s important to remember that as much progress as wellbeing has made since 1948, this is very much a field that is still finding its way. Even the effective altruist community, with its self-assured rhetoric of doing “the most good possible,” <a href="http://www.vox.com/2015/8/10/9124145/effective-altruism-global-ai">is home to raging debates</a> about what exactly that means in practice. So it should come as no surprise that as promising as we feel this direction to be for the arts, we have some thorny questions of our own:</p>
<ul>
<li><b>How does one weigh the benefits of art that is offensive to some people, but empowering to others?</b> This is particularly tricky in cases when art is in direct dialogue &#8212; or conflict &#8212; with ideologies or belief systems that contribute to individuals’ subjective wellbeing. This push-pull appears particular to the field of arts and culture; it’s difficult to imagine how the health, social integration, or financial stability of one person could detract from that of another (beyond instances in which there aren’t enough resources to go around). In contrast, it’s not hard to imagine a scenario in which a culturally important but challenging artistic work has a negative (if short-lived) impact on the subjective wellbeing of the majority of a population. Yet that work may ultimately have a positive impact on <i>future</i> generations, which leads us to a second question:</li>
<li><b>How does one account for changes in the value of arts and cultural products and experiences over time? </b>This dilemma can play out both at the individual level, where cultural experiences that are not immediately pleasurable could nevertheless prove meaningful to the recipient later on; and at a societal level, where future generations may enjoy, appreciate, and/or use today’s cultural products in a very different way than their ancestors do. The latter situation is particularly vexing because there&#8217;s no defined time horizon for our definition of a healthy arts ecosystem, and thus a huge range of possibilities for how many people might be affected positively or negatively in the future by events taking place and decisions made in the present. Fortunately, that particular puzzle is mirrored in domains outside of the arts, and techniques such as discount rates have been established to deal with the issue, imperfect though they may be.</li>
<li><b>How should different elements of wellbeing be weighed against each other? </b>In theory, the only way to answer our opening question of which problems and interventions should receive top priority is to have a clear sense of how the holistic notion of wellbeing relates to its component parts. Yet the actual wellbeing indicator systems that have been put into practice largely seem to avoid this challenge, either declining to offer an overall wellbeing score entirely or weighing each component of the index equally &#8212; which, <a href="http://hdr.undp.org/en/content/inventory-composite-measures-human-progress">as many have pointed out</a>, comes with its own set of problems. More interesting and intellectually defensible ways of determining weights exist, including expert judgments, crowdsourcing the personal opinions of members of the population under study, and statistical methods such as principal component analysis, two-stage factor analysis, or conjoint analysis. We aren’t in a position at this point to recommend a specific weighting scheme, but it seems like an important area for someone to explore going forward.</li>
</ul>
<p>For all our never-ending debates about how and whether to measure the impact of the arts, our field may be well poised to contribute to this complex but fascinating dialogue that spans so many disciplines and decades. After all, if anyone is accustomed to making value judgments within an environment that resists quantification, it’s us! Committing to that conversation could open new doors as we contribute to a broader, shared understanding of human progress without having to downplay some of the arts’ more unique, intrinsic contributions. Entering those doors, however, will require leaving the arts cheerleading that many of us are accustomed to at the coat check. It will require contemplating what it looks like to offer the freedom to participate in arts and culture while simultaneously honoring those who decline the invitation.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
			<wfw:commentRss>https://createquity.com/2015/08/part-of-your-world-on-the-arts-and-wellbeing/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
		<slash:comments>16</slash:comments>
			<dc:creator><![CDATA[Ian David Moss]]></dc:creator>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[John Carnwath]]></dc:creator>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Katie Ingersoll]]></dc:creator>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Fari Nzinga]]></dc:creator>
	</item>
		<item>
		<title>Notes to &#8220;Part of Your World&#8221;</title>
		<link>https://createquity.com/2015/08/notes-to-part-of-your-world/</link>
		<comments>https://createquity.com/2015/08/notes-to-part-of-your-world/#respond</comments>
		<pubDate>Mon, 31 Aug 2015 15:21:30 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Talia Gibas, Ian David Moss, John Carnwath, Katie Ingersoll and Fari Nzinga]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[Insider]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[bibliography]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[capability approach]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[indicators]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[quality of life]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[wellbeing]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://createquity.com/?p=8170</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[The following end notes accompany our article, &#8220;Part of Your World: On the Arts and Wellbeing,&#8221; published on August 31, 2015: [1] For his part, Sen has written a stirring defense of incorporating cultural considerations into international development policy, although his essay does not dwell on explicit connections to the capability approach. [2] Createquity is<a href="https://createquity.com/2015/08/notes-to-part-of-your-world/" class="read-more">Read&#160;More</a>]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The following end notes accompany our article, &#8220;<a href="https://createquity.com/2015/08/part-of-your-world-on-the-arts-and-wellbeing">Part of Your World: On the Arts and Wellbeing</a>,&#8221; published on August 31, 2015:<br />
<a name="anchor1"></a><br />
[1] For his part, Sen has written a <a href="http://www.studentsofferingsupport.ca/portal/OutreachProjects/PreDepReadings/A1_How%20does%20culture%20matter_.pdf">stirring defense</a> of incorporating cultural considerations into international development policy, although his essay does not dwell on explicit connections to the capability approach.<br />
<a name="anchor2"></a><br />
[2] Createquity is by no means the first entity in the arts to attempt a reckoning with wellbeing or the capability approach. Starting with the Urban Institute’s <a href="http://www.metrotrends.org/natdata/acip/">Arts and Culture Indicators in Community Building Project</a>(ACIP) in 1996, a number of scholars and arts organizations have examined the connection from various angles, though more often from the perspective of applying wellbeing concepts to arts and culture policy and practice rather than seeking to understand how arts and culture fit into wellbeing.</p>
<p>Encounters between the arts and the capability approach have been both more recent and rare. The two examples we know of are Samuel Jones’s 2010 monograph <a href="http://www.demos.co.uk/publications/cultureshock"><i>Culture Shock</i></a> for the British think tank Demos, which draws on the capability approach to reframe public policy goals relating to culture in England; and a more quantitative application of the capability approach to the arts undertaken by Mark Stern and Susan Seifert of the University of Pennsylvania’s Social Impact of the Arts Project. Stern and Seifert used a modified version of the capability approach as defined in the Stiglitz-Sen-Fitoussi Commission as a starting point for their <a href="https://createquity.com/2015/03/a-new-way-to-think-about-intrinsic-vs-instrumental-benefits-of-the-arts/">investigation of cultural activity and social wellbeing</a> in Philadelphia and other cities. Their analysis reveals some interesting&#8211;if not entirely conclusive&#8211;patterns of wellbeing and cultural participation in different parts of Philadelphia. They identify areas of concentrated disadvantage in multiple categories of wellbeing which coincide with racial and socioeconomic divides, and point to an increasing correlation over time between neighborhood economic prosperity and cultural access. Nevertheless, Stern and Seifert leave some of the most exciting theoretical implications of the capability approach for the arts unexplored. Despite rhetoric to the contrary, their analysis routinely measures the relationship between cultural activity and wellbeing as if they were separate concepts. This is partly explained by Stern and Seifert’s adaptation of the wellbeing domains from the Stiglitz-Sen-Fitoussi Commission, which do not include culture explicitly. By contrast, at Createquity we feel that there is greater potential to be drawn from Martha Nussbaum’s central human capabilities for reasons discussed in the main article.<br />
<a name="anchor3"></a><br />
[3] In our <a href="https://createquity.com/2014/10/a-healthy-arts-ecosystem/">original definition</a> of a healthy arts ecosystem, we had been drawn to the concept of as popularized by psychologist Abraham Maslow in his famous Hierarchy of Needs to serve this purpose. Our <a href="https://createquity.com/2015/08/research-progress-report-whats-up-with-self-actualization">subsequent research</a>, however, leads us to believe that while self-actualization still enjoys currency in American popular culture (particularly in the business world), in the social sciences it is seen as an increasingly dated and culturally-specific concept. Nussbaum’s central human capabilities may eventually fall prey to similar criticisms, but overall they seem to be a clear improvement over the framework initially proposed in our healthy arts ecosystem definition and a step towards both internal clarity and interoperability with other social innovation initiatives.</p>
<h3>FULL BIBLIOGRAPHY</h3>
<p>Agenda 21 for Culture. (n.d.). Culture as a goal in post-2015. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.agenda21culture.net/index.php/documents/culture-as-a-goal-in-post-2015">http://www.agenda21culture.net/index.php/documents/culture-as-a-goal-in-post-2015</a></p>
<p>Agenda 21 for Culture. (2015). Recognizing the Role of Culture to Strengthen the UN Post-2015 Development Agenda. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.culture2015goal.net/images/yootheme/culture2015/def/Indicators_ENG.pdf">http://www.culture2015goal.net/images/yootheme/culture2015/def/Indicators_ENG.pdf</a></p>
<p>Alkire, S. (2008). The Capability Approach to the Quality of Life. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.commission-stiglitz-sen-fitoussi.fr/documents/capability_approach.pdf">http://www.commission-stiglitz-sen-fitoussi.fr/documents/capability_approach.pdf</a></p>
<p>All-Party Parliamentary Group on Wellbeing Economics. September 2014. “Wellbeing in Four Policy Areas. Retrieved from <a href="http://b.3cdn.net/nefoundation/ccdf9782b6d8700f7c_lcm6i2ed7.pdf" target="_blank">http://b.3cdn.net/nefoundation/ccdf9782b6d8700f7c_lcm6i2ed7.pdf</a></p>
<p>Alonso, G., &amp; Medici, M. (2014). <i>UNESCO Culture for Development Indicators: Methodology Manual</i>. UNESCO. Retrieved from <a href="http://en.unesco.org/creativity/sites/creativity/files/digital-library/CDIS%20Methodology%20Manual_0.pdf">http://en.unesco.org/creativity/sites/creativity/files/digital-library/CDIS%20Methodology%20Manual_0.pdf</a></p>
<p>Arts Council England. (2014). The Value of Arts and Culture to People and Society: An Evidence Review. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.artscouncil.org.uk/media/uploads/pdf/The-value-of-arts-and-culture-to-people-and-society-An-evidence-review-TWO.pdf">http://www.artscouncil.org.uk/media/uploads/pdf/The-value-of-arts-and-culture-to-people-and-society-An-evidence-review-TWO.pdf</a></p>
<p>Bauer, R. (Ed.). (1966). <i>Social Indicators</i>. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.</p>
<p>Canadian Index of Wellbeing. (2012). How are Canadians Really Doing? 2012 CIW Report. Waterloo, ON: Canadian Index of Wellbeing and University of Waterloo. Retrieved from <a href="https://uwaterloo.ca/canadian-index-wellbeing/sites/ca.canadian-index-wellbeing/files/uploads/files/CIW2012-HowAreCanadiansReallyDoing-23Oct2012_0.pdf">https://uwaterloo.ca/canadian-index-wellbeing/sites/ca.canadian-index-wellbeing/files/uploads/files/CIW2012-HowAreCanadiansReallyDoing-23Oct2012_0.pdf</a></p>
<p>Carnwath, J. D. &amp; Brown, A. S. (2014). Understanding the Value and Impacts of Cultural Experiences: A Literature Review. WolfBrown and Arts Council England. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.artscouncil.org.uk/media/uploads/pdf/Understanding_the_value_and_impacts_of_cultural_experiences.pdf">http://www.artscouncil.org.uk/media/uploads/pdf/Understanding_the_value_and_impacts_of_cultural_experiences.pdf</a></p>
<p>Chancel, L. (2014). Beyond GDP indicators: To what end? Retrieved from <a href="http://oecdinsights.org/2014/11/25/7388/">http://oecdinsights.org/2014/11/25/7388/</a></p>
<p>Cobb, C. &amp; Rixford C. (1998). Lessons learned from the history of social indicators. San Francisco, CA: Redefining Progress.</p>
<p>Dodge, R., Daly, A. P., Huyton, J., &amp; Sanders, L. D. (2012). The challenge of defining wellbeing. <em>International Journal of Wellbeing</em>, 2(3), 222–235.</p>
<p>Easterlin, R. (1974). Does Economic Growth Improve the Human Lot? Some Empirical Evidence. In David, P. A. &amp; Reder, M. W. (Eds.), <i>Nations and Households in Economic Growth: Essays in Honor of Moses Abramovitz</i>. New York. Retrieved from <a href="http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2008/04/16/business/Easterlin1974.pdf">http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2008/04/16/business/Easterlin1974.pdf</a></p>
<p>Fujiwara, D. (2013). Museum’s and Happiness: The Value of Participating in Museums and the Arts. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.happymuseumproject.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Museums_and_happiness_DFujiwara_April2013.pdf">http://www.happymuseumproject.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Museums_and_happiness_DFujiwara_April2013.pdf</a></p>
<p>Fujiwara, D., Kudrna, L., &amp; Dolan, P. (2014). Quantifying and Valuing the Wellbeing Impacts of Culture and Sport. Department for Culture, Media and Sport. Retrieved from <a href="https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/304899/Quantifying_and_valuing_the_wellbeing_impacts_of_sport_and_culture.pdf">https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/304899/Quantifying_and_valuing_the_wellbeing_impacts_of_sport_and_culture.pdf</a></p>
<p>Fujiwara, D., Kudrna, L., &amp; Dolan, P. (2014b). Quantifying the Social Impacts of Culture and Sport. Scotland Department of Culture, Media and Sport. Retrieved from <a href="https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/304896/Quantifying_the_Social_Impacts_of_Culture_and_Sport.pdf">https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/304896/Quantifying_the_Social_Impacts_of_Culture_and_Sport.pdf</a></p>
<p>Gallup-Healthways Well-Being Index. (n.d.). Retrieved from <a href="http://www.well-beingindex.com/">http://www.well-beingindex.com/</a></p>
<p>GDP: A Flawed Measure of Progress | New Economy Working Group. (n.d.). Retrieved from <a href="http://www.neweconomyworkinggroup.org/visions/living-wealth-indicators/gdp-flawed-measure-progress">http://www.neweconomyworkinggroup.org/visions/living-wealth-indicators/gdp-flawed-measure-progress</a></p>
<p>Hagerty, M. R., Cummins, R., Ferriss, A. L., Land, K., Michalos, A. C., Peterson, M., … Vogel, J. (2001). Quality of Life Indexes for National Policy: Review and Agenda for Research. Bulletin de Methodologie Sociologique, 71(1), 58–78. Retrieved from <a href="http://doi.org/10.1177/075910630107100104">http://doi.org/10.1177/075910630107100104</a></p>
<p>The Hangzhou Declaration: Placing Culture at the Heart of Sustainable Development Policies. (2013). Presented at the Hangzhou International Conference China. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.unesco.org/new/fileadmin/MULTIMEDIA/HQ/CLT/images/FinalHangzhouDeclaration20130517.pdf">http://www.unesco.org/new/fileadmin/MULTIMEDIA/HQ/CLT/images/FinalHangzhouDeclaration20130517.pdf</a></p>
<p>Jackson, M.-R., &amp; Herranz, J. (2002). Culture Counts in Communities: A Framework for Measurement (Research Report). The Urban Institute. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.urban.org/UploadedPDF/310834_culture_counts.pdf">http://www.urban.org/UploadedPDF/310834_culture_counts.pdf</a></p>
<p>Jackson, M.-R., Kabwasa-Green, F., &amp; Herranz, J. (2006). Cultural Vitality in Communities: Interpretation and Indicators. The Urban Institute. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.urban.org/research/publication/cultural-vitality-communities-interpretation-and-indicators">http://www.urban.org/research/publication/cultural-vitality-communities-interpretation-and-indicators</a></p>
<p>Jones, S. (2010). Culture Shock. London: Demos. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.demos.co.uk/files/Culture_shock_-_web.pdf?1286815564">http://www.demos.co.uk/files/Culture_shock_-_web.pdf?1286815564</a></p>
<p>Langlois, A., &amp; Anderson, D. E. (2002). Resolving the Quality of Life/Well-being Puzzle: Toward a New Model. <em>Canadian Journal of Regional Science</em>, 25(3), 501–512.</p>
<p>The Lottery of Life. (2012). The Economist. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.economist.com/news/21566430-where-be-born-2013-lottery-life">http://www.economist.com/news/21566430-where-be-born-2013-lottery-life</a></p>
<p>The Lottery of Life Methodology. (2012). The Economist. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.economist.com/news/21567049-how-we-calculated-life-satisfaction-lottery-life-methodology">http://www.economist.com/news/21567049-how-we-calculated-life-satisfaction-lottery-life-methodology</a></p>
<p>Matarasso, F. (1997). Use or Ornament? The Social Impact of Participation in the Arts. Comedia. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.feisean.org/downloads/Use-or-Ornament.pdf">http://www.feisean.org/downloads/Use-or-Ornament.pdf</a></p>
<p>McCarthy, K., Ondaatje, E., Zakaras, L., Brooks, A., &amp; RAND. (2004). Gifts of the Muse: Reframing the Debate About the Benefits of the Arts. RAND. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/monographs/2005/RAND_MG218.pdf">http://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/monographs/2005/RAND_MG218.pdf</a></p>
<p>Medvedeva, M., Novak-Leonard, J., Brown, A. (2011). Audience Impact Study: Literature Review. National Endowment for the Arts. Retrieved from <a href="http://arts.gov/sites/default/files/Audience-Impact-Study-Literature-Review.pdf">http://arts.gov/sites/default/files/Audience-Impact-Study-Literature-Review.pdf</a></p>
<p>Michalos, A.C., Smale, B., Labonté, R., Muharjarine, N., Scott, K., Moore, K., … Hyman, I. (2011). The Canadian Index of Wellbeing. Technical Report 1.0. Waterloo, ON: Canadian Index of Wellbeing and University of Waterloo. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.unesco.org/new/fileadmin/MULTIMEDIA/HQ/CLT/pdf/canadianindexofwellbeingtechnicalpaper.pdf">http://www.unesco.org/new/fileadmin/MULTIMEDIA/HQ/CLT/pdf/canadianindexofwellbeingtechnicalpaper.pdf</a></p>
<p>National Endowment for the Arts. (2012). How Art Works. Retrieved from http://arts.gov/sites/default/files/How-Art-Works_0.pdf</p>
<p>Noll, H. (2004). Social Indicators and Quality of Life Research: Background, Achievements and Current Trends. In N. Genov (Ed.), Advances in Sociological Knowledge (pp. 151–181). Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.</p>
<p>OECD. (2013). How’s Life? 2013. OECD Publishing. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/economics/how-s-life-2013_9789264201392-en">http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/economics/how-s-life-2013_9789264201392-en</a></p>
<p>OECD. (2014). Society at a Glance 2014. OECD Publishing. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/social-issues-migration-health/society-at-a-glance-2014_soc_glance-2014-en">http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/social-issues-migration-health/society-at-a-glance-2014_soc_glance-2014-en</a></p>
<p>OECD Better Life Index. (n.d.). Retrieved January 24, 2015, from <a href="http://www.oecdbetterlifeindex.org/">http://www.oecdbetterlifeindex.org/</a></p>
<p>Prescott-Allen, R. (2001). The Wellbeing of Nations: A Country-By-Country Index of Quality of Life and the Environment (1 edition). Washington, DC: Island Press.</p>
<p>Scottish Government, S. A. H. (2006). Quality of Life and Well-being: Measuring the Benefits of Culture and Sport: Literature Review and Thinkpiece [Research Publications]. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Publications/2006/01/13110743/0">http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Publications/2006/01/13110743/0</a></p>
<p>Sen, A. (2004). How does culture matter?. In V. Rao &amp; M. Walton (Eds.), Culture and Public Action. Stanford UP. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.studentsofferingsupport.ca/portal/OutreachProjects/PreDepReadings/A1_How%20does%20culture%20matter_.pdf">http://www.studentsofferingsupport.ca/portal/OutreachProjects/PreDepReadings/A1_How%20does%20culture%20matter_.pdf</a></p>
<p>Social Progress Index – Methodology. (2014). Retrieved January 22, 2015, from <a href="http://www.socialprogressimperative.org/data/spi/methodology">http://www.socialprogressimperative.org/data/spi/methodology</a></p>
<p>Stern, M. J., &amp; Seifert, S.C. (2013). Cultural Ecology, Neighborhood Vitality, and Social Wellbeing – A Philadelphia Project. University of Pennsylvania Social Impact of the Arts Project (SIAP). Retrieved from <a href="http://arts.gov/exploring-our-town/sites/arts.gov.exploring-our-town/files/SIAP%20CULTUREBLOCKS%20REPORT%20DEC2013%20V1.pdf">http://arts.gov/exploring-our-town/sites/arts.gov.exploring-our-town/files/SIAP%20CULTUREBLOCKS%20REPORT%20DEC2013%20V1.pdf</a></p>
<p>Stiglitz, J. E., Sen, A., &amp; Fitoussi, J.P. (2009). Report by the Commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social Progress. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.stiglitz-sen-fitoussi.fr/documents/rapport_anglais.pdf">http://www.stiglitz-sen-fitoussi.fr/documents/rapport_anglais.pdf</a></p>
<p>Stone, A. &amp; Mackie, C., eds. Subjective Well-Being: Measuring Happiness, Suffering, and Other Dimensions of Experience. (2013). Retrieved from <a href="http://www.nap.edu/catalog/18548/subjective-well-being-measuring-happiness-suffering-and-other-dimensions-of">http://www.nap.edu/catalog/18548/subjective-well-being-measuring-happiness-suffering-and-other-dimensions-of</a></p>
<p>The Story of GNH | GNH Centre Bhutan. (n.d.). Retrieved from <a href="http://www.gnhcentrebhutan.org/what-is-gnh/the-story-of-gnh/">http://www.gnhcentrebhutan.org/what-is-gnh/the-story-of-gnh/</a></p>
<p>Tepper, S. (2014). Artful Living: Examining the Relationship Between Artistic Practice and Subjective Wellbeing Across Three National Surveys. The Curb Center for Art, Enterprise, and Public Policy at Vanderbilt University. Retrieved from <a href="http://arts.gov/sites/default/files/Research-Art-Works-Vanderbilt.pdf">http://arts.gov/sites/default/files/Research-Art-Works-Vanderbilt.pdf</a></p>
<p>Topos Partnership for the Fine Arts Fund. (2010). The Arts Ripple Effect: A Research-Based Strategy to Build Shared Responsibility for the Arts. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.theartswave.org/docs/default-source/Research-Reports/the-arts-ripple-effect-report-january-2010.pdf?sfvrsn=0">http://www.theartswave.org/docs/default-source/Research-Reports/the-arts-ripple-effect-report-january-2010.pdf?sfvrsn=0</a></p>
<p>United Nations Development Programme. (n.d.). Human Development Index (HDI). Retrieved January 23, 2015, from <a href="http://hdr.undp.org/en/content/human-development-index-hdi">http://hdr.undp.org/en/content/human-development-index-hdi</a></p>
<p>United Nations Development Programme. (n.d.). Inequality-Adjusted Human Development Index (IHDI). Retrieved January 23, 2015, from <a href="http://hdr.undp.org/en/content/inequality-adjusted-human-development-index-ihdi">http://hdr.undp.org/en/content/inequality-adjusted-human-development-index-ihdi</a></p>
<p>Ura, K., Alkire, S., Zangmo, T., Wangdi, K. (2012). A Short Guide to Gross National Happiness. (n.d.). Thimphu, Bhutan: Centre for Bhutan Studies. Retrieved January 23, 2015, from <a href="http://www.grossnationalhappiness.com/">http://www.grossnationalhappiness.com/</a></p>
<p>Urban Institute. (2014). The Validating Arts &amp; Livability Indicators (VALI) Study: Results and Recommendations. Retrieved January 23, 2015, from <a href="http://arts.gov/sites/default/files/VALI-Report.pdf">http://arts.gov/sites/default/files/VALI-Report.pdf</a></p>
<p>Yang, L. (2014). An Inventory of Composite Measures of Human Progress | Human Development Reports. UNDP Human Development Report Office. Retrieved from <a href="http://hdr.undp.org/en/content/inventory-composite-measures-human-progress">http://hdr.undp.org/en/content/inventory-composite-measures-human-progress</a></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
]]></content:encoded>
			<wfw:commentRss>https://createquity.com/2015/08/notes-to-part-of-your-world/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
		<slash:comments>0</slash:comments>
			<dc:creator><![CDATA[Ian David Moss]]></dc:creator>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[John Carnwath]]></dc:creator>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Katie Ingersoll]]></dc:creator>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Fari Nzinga]]></dc:creator>
	</item>
		<item>
		<title>Research Progress Report: What&#8217;s Up with Self-Actualization?</title>
		<link>https://createquity.com/2015/08/research-progress-report-whats-up-with-self-actualization/</link>
		<comments>https://createquity.com/2015/08/research-progress-report-whats-up-with-self-actualization/#respond</comments>
		<pubDate>Mon, 31 Aug 2015 15:19:11 +0000</pubDate>
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[John Carnwath and Talia Gibas]]></dc:creator>
				<category><![CDATA[Insider]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[core research process]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Maslow's hierarchy of needs]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[self-actualization]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[subjective wellbeing]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[wellbeing]]></category>

		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://createquity.com/?p=8143</guid>
		<description><![CDATA[While the term continues to be bandied about with some regularity, there does not appear to be one agreed-upon definition of self-actualization and there is a lack of empirical support for Maslow’s hierarchy.]]></description>
				<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="attachment_8145" style="width: 570px" class="wp-caption aligncenter"><a href="https://flic.kr/p/4XBrXf"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" aria-describedby="caption-attachment-8145" class="wp-image-8145" src="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/2598393808_c26f6a4bea_o.jpg" alt="2598393808_c26f6a4bea_o" width="560" height="641" srcset="https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/2598393808_c26f6a4bea_o.jpg 1697w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/2598393808_c26f6a4bea_o-262x300.jpg 262w, https://createquity.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/2598393808_c26f6a4bea_o-894x1024.jpg 894w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 560px) 100vw, 560px" /></a><p id="caption-attachment-8145" class="wp-caption-text">&#8220;Maslow&#8217;s Real Hierarchy&#8221; by Mike Kline</p></div>
<p><em>Note: Createquity&#8217;s original definition of a healthy arts ecosystem included references to self-actualization as one of the benefits of the arts. We weren&#8217;t sure about how self-actualization and Maslow&#8217;s hierarchy of needs were viewed in the research field, however, so we conducted a bit of due diligence to come to a stronger understanding. This work eventually led us to a large body of research on wellbeing, about which we <a href="https://createquity.com/2015/08/part-of-your-world-on-the-arts-and-wellbeing/">published a feature article</a> in August 2015.</em></p>
<p><em>These initial research reports were completed in 2014 by members of the Createquity editorial team. They are intended to give a sense of our (very) preliminary thoughts on the topic in question. We welcome discussion and debate. – IDM</em></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p><b>A bit about our process</b></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Rather than generating specific hypotheses regarding the relationship between self-actualization and the arts, we did a scan of existing literature on self-actualization, wellbeing, and identity to get a rough sense of possible answers to the following questions:</span></p>
<ul>
<li style="font-weight: 400;"><span style="font-weight: 400;">How seriously do psychologists and social theorists take self-actualization today?</span></li>
<li style="font-weight: 400;"><span style="font-weight: 400;">If it does have currency today, does self-actualization have a generally accepted scientific meaning and if so, what is that meaning?</span></li>
<li style="font-weight: 400;"><span style="font-weight: 400;">What is the relationship between self-actualization and more &#8220;basic&#8221; needs? Is it possible to reach self-actualization without other needs having been met first?</span></li>
</ul>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">After doing a preliminary “data dump” into Zotero, compiling articles and reports on Maslow’s theory of self-actualization and alternate theories, we paused to determine the best way to move forward. Falling down the rabbit hole of “Was Maslow right or not?” was tempting, but we decided to expand beyond self-actualization specifically while refocusing our energies in two broad areas: examining literature related to the arts and psychological wellbeing, and literature related to the arts and identity. We also each read a handful of articles that emerged during our initial scan and seemed to be particularly relevant.</span></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p><b>Extent to which existing research addresses our research questions, and extent to which there seem to be areas of consensus and debate</b></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">We found a lot of literature on Maslow’s theory of self-actualization and its application to a range of disciplines (i.e. management theory, mental health). As noted above, whether or not Maslow was “correct” is still hotly contested. Wahba and Bridwell’s literature review of research on Maslow concludes that his theory has been generally disproven. That review, however, focused on research inside the workplace. Another seminal report, Tay and Diener’s “Needs and Subjective Well Being Around the World,” found there are specific categories of need that are consistent across cultures, and there is some suggestion of a needs “hierarchy” that is more fluid than Maslow suggested. They did not explicitly mention self-actualization in their survey, choosing instead of examine individuals’ feelings of mastery/pride in work, self-direction, and autonomy. However, in speaking about the study, one of its authors did refer to self-actualization, noting, “An important departure from Maslow’s theory is that we found that a person can report having good social relationships and self-actualization even if their basic needs and safety needs are not completely fulfilled.” </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">In short,  while the term continues to be bandied about with some regularity, there does not appear to be one agreed-upon definition of self-actualization and there is a lack of empirical support for Maslow’s hierarchy. In popular literature, Maslow’s pyramid is referred to “quaint and old-fashioned and badly in need of updating.” There is also another, more </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">philosophical critique of the self-actualization idea that questions Maslow’s assumption of there being a stable Self that merely needs to be “actualized.” We didn’t find studies that directly take Maslow to task for this (and we may be  exaggerating his essentialism as we haven’t read his work ourselves), but it seems inherent in the way that postmodern theorists and identity studies scholars talk about identity formation.  </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">From our vantage points as neophytes in psychological research, however, it appears that the concept of self-actualization has been folded into broader discussions of psychic wellbeing, and may be the cornerstone of the burgeoning field of “positive psychology,” which studies the conditions that make people happy as opposed to the conditions/symptoms of psychological distress.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Lacking an agreed-upon definition of what self-actualization is and how it can be achieved, we had difficulty moving forward on the majority of our other research questions. However, we did find a few tidbits here and there.  A rough summary of  questions and relevant notes follows:</span></p>
<ul>
<li><b><i><b><i>What is the relationship between self-actualization and overall life satisfaction? Have there been any studies looking at both?</i></b></i></b>
<ul>
<li><span style="font-weight: 400;">A 2004 study by Vitterso argues that self-actualization and subjective wellbeing are two separate things. The author cites a lot of literature in outlining the two concepts. Interestingly, Vitterso doesn’t cite Maslow on self-actualization and indeed we&#8217;re not sure how closely Vitterso’s use of the term resonates with Maslow (Vitterso certainly isn’t interested in the hierarchy of needs). For Vitterso, SWB is a form of happiness that is related to “being” while self-actualization is related to “doing.” Without reading up on the literature that Vitterso cites, we can’t tell how/if “self-actualization” differs from a more general sense of “personal development.” Vitterso’s use of the term certainly seems to imply that its the process of self-actualization that is important (i.e. that makes people happy) rather than being self-actualized.  Vitterso concludes that “that traditional measurements of SWB are insensitive to important aspects of human lives, and that the concept misses important aspects of psychological well-being.”</span></li>
<li><span style="font-weight: 400;">Tay and Diener’s international survey of subjective wellbeing doesn’t mention self-actualization at all, but instead uses terms of self-direction and autonomy.</span></li>
</ul>
</li>
</ul>
<ul>
<li><b><i><b><i>What is the relationship between self-actualization and more &#8220;basic&#8221; needs? Is it possible to reach self-actualization without other needs having been met first?</i></b></i></b>
<ul>
<li><span style="font-weight: 400;">From article on “Renovating the pyramid of needs”: The researchers state in the article that while self-actualization is interesting and important, it isn’t an evolutionarily fundamental need. Instead, many of the activities that Maslow labeled as self-actualizing (artistic creativity, for example) reflect more biologically basic drives to gain status, which in turn serves the goal of attracting mates.</span></li>
<li><span style="font-weight: 400;">Tay and Diener found that while there is some evidence of a consistent hierarchy across countries, it is indeed possible to fulfill “higher” needs first &#8212; i.e. to report strong social relationships and feelings of love and belonging without necessarily having all basic needs secured.</span></li>
</ul>
</li>
</ul>
<ul>
<li><b><i><b><i>How do scholars who specialize in self-actualization see the arts fitting in? What are examples of other pathways to self-actualization that don&#8217;t involve the arts</i></b></i></b>
<ul>
<li><span style="font-weight: 400;">There doesn’t seem to be much research that addresses this specifically. (We found a few articles that purport to look at the relationship between a specific art form and self-actualization, but they did not not appear to be robust studies.) The closest parallel might be Mikhail Csikszentmihalyi’s concept of “flow,” which is frequently brought up in discussion of creativity and education. Flow is not specific to the arts, however; it can be achieved through any individual activity provided that activity triggers the right combination of passion and challenge in a given person.</span></li>
</ul>
</li>
</ul>
<ul>
<li><b><i><b><i>Do we have any idea how many people are self-actualized, whatever that means? How would one go about estimating this?</i></b></i></b>
<ul>
<li><span style="font-weight: 400;">If the initial scan of the Vitterso study is correct, self-actualization doesn’t refer to a state which some people have reached and others haven’t, it refers to the a person’s relationship to a particular task/experience. Vitterso cites the theory of “flow” experiences which roughly states that people are most happy when they are challenged but able to fulfill the task. </span></li>
</ul>
</li>
</ul>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p><b>Where do we go from here?</b></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Unless we want to come up with our own definition of the term, self-actualization may be a dead end. However, further investigation of how psychologists and other researchers characterize subjective wellbeing, and the relationship between SWB and autonomy and creativity may be warranted. It may also be worth looking into how SWB manifests across communities, not just individuals &#8212; one critique of Maslow’s pyramid is that it is oriented to an individual’s experience at the expense of collective experience. Arts engagement cultivates both, and Tay and Diener’s work touches on how the attributes of a specific country or community can influence the likelihood of individuals reporting higher SWB.</span></p>
]]></content:encoded>
			<wfw:commentRss>https://createquity.com/2015/08/research-progress-report-whats-up-with-self-actualization/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
		<slash:comments>0</slash:comments>
			<dc:creator><![CDATA[Talia Gibas]]></dc:creator>
	</item>
	</channel>
</rss>
